2. music
  3. 1244926021

Music and politics

A post yesterday about U2 prompted me to listen to them today. And one comment from yesterday got me to thinking. The author wrote dismissively that they should "keep their politics to themselves." (Those may or may not have been the exact words, but that gets to the point.) As I've been listening this afternoon, I've thought: I'm neither a born-again Christian nor a political leftie, but I do love this band. And then I thought further: If I listened only to bands or singer-songwriters whose politics were like mine, I surely wouldn't spin a whole lot of recordings. (For the record, I consider myself a radically pragmatic centrist with occasional libertarian leanings. Got any bands who'd fill that bill?) I care about the music, and not about what the people making that music happen to believe. Am I alone in this? Do others dismiss certain artists because of their politics -- or religion or the kind of car they drive or whatever else?
hodu
50svinyl
3 posts
 
Beethoven for more conservative right winger. Brahms, Mozart, Chopin, Debussy, Ravel, et al. for everybody else.
chatta
314 posts
 
I not care much about a musicians politics. I might not listen to their music if I thought is sent out a negative message to society, however.
ozzy's avatar
ozzy
7,451 posts
 
I have an idea.
The Musicians who want to rant about there political views with the captive audience in concert should make an announcement at the beginning of the show.

That announcement could be like,” After the Concert, the group (Artist) will spend a few moments sharing his / hers political viewpoints."

Watch how many people split after the music is over...
bongofury
1,160 posts
 
Ozzy

There is a photo on the cover on the new Woodie Guthrie box set that shows him in a coffee shop with a sticker on his guitar that says "This guitar kills facists".

I totally disagree that the audience should dictate the terms that an artist follows. You have it all wrong, IMHO.
What makes this country great is free expression in open forums. You are there to see the artist, and their thoughts are just as important as their music. What holds true for Woodie in 1930s, holds true today.

It will never be only about the music. If you believe that, listen to instrumental bands. If this upsets you: quit going to see politically-minded bands. That is your freedom of choice.
macdadtexas
1,794 posts
 
Rock Musicians are in most cases under-educated, over confindent idiot liberals.

Country Musicians are in most cases under-educated, over confident idoit conservatives.

I think I am going to stick to instrumental Jazz and Classical. At least in those instances when I don't agree with one side or the other, I think they have had enough education and real world experience to make a logical arguement.
More to discover