This strictly my opinion. In theory no. The whole package and the stand is very important. In practice, yes everything makes a difference, but after you get to a decent table like a Rega 3, or better yet a 25, the cartridge becomes very important. The stand is also important. That being said I have an Oracle V with upgraded power supply, a Graham 2.0 and a Lyra Helicon with a tube phono pre. Most of this is lost if your records are not clean. On the other hand I have listened to a MMF-3 with a phenomena phono pre get the music right and sound superior to a $5k CD circa 1999. I repeat milage may vary. Enjoy the music.
Hope this helps
Hope this helps