question about wire break in

Q: What's breaking in?
A: For the most part, the human brain.

Don't underestimate what it is capable of learning WHILE the metals and dialectics are changing.

Don't forget how gullible it can be either. Google "hypnotism" and "effect of suggestion" then go read "some" cable ads.

Trust your ears. If you hear something....good, if you don't....good. Only an idiot would try and tell you that "you" do or don't hear a difference.

Human hearing is very acute (thank you evolution) and right off the bat one can tell if something is amiss even if one is not all that familiar with that something to begin with. Anomalies, when presented, can confound and present themselves as unpleasant, smeared and incoherent. We instinctively know what sounds real.

It doesn't take an expert to doubt what one hears and not be able to put it to words. No amount of time will make it better for the brain to accept if it doesn't change. I'll grant that as time goes by some folk will settle for less but the cable is breaking in.

I've yet to be hypnotized by a cable but I can see where a cobra would get my attention rather quickly and make me do something I wouldn't normally do.

All the best,
Nonoise

A great many explanations can be offered for what MAY be occurring when cable breakin effects are perceived, including those cited in the Cardas paper Mofi linked to, and in the IMO well stated comments that were presented by Mr. Rodman (which I don't see any basis to dispute).

The problem is that none of the explanations that tend to be offered by cable manufacturers or others ever seem to be backed up by analysis establishing in a QUANTITATIVE manner that the claimed effects have a reasonable chance of being audibly significant. In fairness, though, perhaps it is generally not practical or possible for that to be done.

Thus, IMO there is no way to tell how many reports of perceived cable breakin are due to any one or more of the various technical effects that are alleged to occur; or to the placebo effect (coupled with the power of suggestion of the many claims that can be found in manufacturer literature and on the 'net); or to the vagaries of human perception that Onemug alluded to; or, perhaps most significantly in many cases, to failure to recognize and control extraneous variables (for example, assuring identical states of equipment warmup during the different parts of the assessment, ruling out the possibility that changes in AC line voltage or noise conditions may have occurred, ruling out the possibility that ongoing aging or breakin of system components may be occurring, etc.).

My bottom line instinct is that cable breakin effects are real, to some degree, but their significance is exaggerated in the minds of many audiophiles by these other factors.

Regards,
-- Al

Lmr,

Wire "break-in" is all hogwash, and all the long-winded explanations proffered by some are gobbley gook with zero basis in the principles of electrical engineering. Save your money and your sanity...traditional stranded copper cable of sufficient gauge is all you need.