Smoke Head or Sherry Bomb?


Occasionally there's some discussion here about single malts. Just wondering what our preferences are?
"Smoke/peat heads"; Islay, laphraoig, Lagavulin, Ardbeg etc. or "Sherry Bombs" Macallans, Glendronach etc.
128x128rja
Yes, I know the examples cited were extreme but a previous poster asked what rarities might cost. These are about as rare as they get.
As mentioned, good single malt whiskys can be had for much, much less.

On Monday, a cold, rainy night I was trying to remember the thread, but could only decide on a 10 year Glenmorangie which so far seems like it was a good idea.

$38 at my local discounter, so I hope not the Bose Wave Radio of single malts, but with the savings vs. Rja's suggestions, I can buy a new car and stereo.
My usually Laphroaig 10 goes for around $42 around here. I recently purchased the Laphroaig 18 for right around $85.
I tasted the new 18yo Laphroaig on Sunday at a friends, thought it was excellent. I saw it at a local bottle shop for $64 but $85 is probably closer to normal.

We also tasted an 18yo Longrow, 1969 25yo Bowmore and 17yo Ardbeg (no longer available). Quite a night :^).

BTW: Found 1/2 bottle of the Bowmore and 2/3 bottle of the Ardbeg in one of my kitchen cabinets. Some other stuff was in front of it.

BTW2: I've tasted 25yo and 30yo Laphroaig and the 30yo might be my favorite whisky of all time.
Wow, I thought these were new strains of herb. Who would drink Scotch when man gave us rum.