phono/preamp analog front end


I have a great, older  analog system...Oracle/Graham 1.5t Ceramic/Ortofon A95/Classe DR-6(modified/refurbished)/Threshold 4000 (modified)/Von Schweikert VR4.5 Silver with all nice power cords/interconnects.....considering upgrading preamp...used vs  new, looking to spend about $5K....could stick with SS, get used Pass Labs XP-15/X2.5 for <$5k....never ventured into tubes.....no convenient stores for me to go to....any thoughts?

128x128jw944ts
ARC Ref 2SE Phono gets my vote.  You'll have to pay a little more, but worth it.  There's one for $5500 at USAM - you could try and bring the price down a little.  It has a gain of 74 dB and balanced output. 
The Herron VTPH2A is in your price range. It sounds great, and I always hoped it was competently designed but never knew for sure until now- no loading switches!

The Herron uses external loading plugs, although the designer feels it sounds best unloaded. 
@sandthemall: I agree with you! I can't think of a way that resistive/capacitive loading can effect the stiffness (Young's Modulus) of a cantilever! 
He doesn’t refer to the actual stiffness of the cantilever, but to the electromagnetic damping effect the loading applies, which affects the compliance of the moving system, I think...