OP doesn't mention a streamer nor what the primary source for music might be. I suggest analog from the disc player go directly to the preamp as well as HDMI to a processor or AVR. That assumes the disc player has a decent DAC. The TT would continue to go directly to the preamp. If OP's preamp has a mode that by-passes its volume control, analog LR from the processor or AVR also goes to the preamp. And analog from a future streamer would go directly to the preamp.
db