Why Music Has Lost it’s Charms (Article)

Again, mahgister, sheet music was around way before Edison. Commercially available sheet music...hit songs of the time..

Again.... 😁😊

Sheet music was not ONLY and MAINLY a "commercial" business, it was a cultural necessity first to make playing family and musical education a general societal fact... The commercial aspect here are subordinated to the musical activity....

The fact that i will buy a wedding ring and a dress, does not make love a business, or a commercial sex enterprise...Internet will do it on s scale so great that it will make old prostitution business a primitive economical game ....

Like recording and vinyl albums will make music an "object" to sell more than an event...We can buy a violin or sell it too this does not make music a "commercial" affair...And someone claiming sheet music make music a business is not wrong but it extend and distort the meaning of the activity out of his limits... Music begun to be a business after recording invention...And after the development of modern marketing technique many aspects of music begin to be a consumers objects instead of being mainly a spiritual activity...

With Edison and the marketing of music playback with recording, music begin to be a product itself, an no more mainly a spiritual event ....

The musical activity here became subordinated to the commercial goals...

Much of the music from the 60's is long lost in our memories (ditto the 70's). We remember the good stuff, or more specifically, we remember the stuff that generates the highest emotional engagement, which does not need to be the highest emotional engagement in everyone, but a high enough emotional engagement in enough people to keep the memory alive:

On the other hand, if you take away the recency effect it’s hard to see which albums from the last 20 years will make the cut a century from now.

I copied a list from Wikipedia of the top songs of 1969. How many of those do you remember clearly? "I can't get next to you" by the Temptations I had no memory of. Same for "I'll never fall in love again". "Sugar Sugar", "Everyday People" .... will never forgot those songs, and can sing word for word. They generate strong positive emotions. It was a particularly good year though. Go to a bar and watch what songs younger people are emotionally engaging with when played. Those will last.

Great remarks...

Much of the music from the 60’s is long lost in our memories (ditto the 70’s). We remember the good stuff, or more specifically, we remember the stuff that generates the highest emotional engagement, which does not need to be the highest emotional engagement in everyone, but a high enough emotional engagement in enough people to keep the memory alive:

There exist great musicians and singers more than ever today, but they are marginalized by bad commercial products...

We have access to great Chinese music, Indian one, Persian, one Nordic Jazz, etc...

Music today is stronger than ever....

But medias are owned by few people....Publicity and marketing , fabrication of products, polluted official mediums...

We will remember great music in decades to come , not because we will listen to it on radio like in the 50 or 60, but because we will stumble on it using peripheral channels to access it...It is my case....

Commercial music of today is horrible... Uglier than possible...

But there is more great music and musicians now than ever...

If is is great music, why are none of those awful media people trying to promote it and make money off of it?  

Commercial music of today is horrible... Uglier than possible...

As music is nothing ever more than a personal experience, this is your opinion, not fact.

Wow, this guy sure has a lot of time to have listened to all 'commercial music of today', whatever that is - I guess the music he likes is not intended to be sold - and make a blanket condemnation of all of it.

Or is it more "I don't like it so it's horrible and ugly!!!". Never seen that attitude before....🤣