Why not horns?

He apparently has ears and has listened to a lot of stuff.

The same credentials as most of us I would say.

He also indicates he is "a longtime proponent and user of Walsh speaker technology".

And he indicates he writes a syndicated consumer electronics column. So he is apparently a (gasp) journalist!

So much for credibility?

Its funny reading some of these comments. I wonder if some people just say what they read in a audiophile magazine.

Sthomas - I agree. Probably. Can you elaborate as to what comments are funny and why?

re: Walsh drivers in horns, I know nothing about the credibility of the reviewer but I do know that German Physics is a legitimate and highly credible manufacturer who is unlikely to market a product that is utterly without merit. We should probably withhold judgement until we have actually heard them.

I don't think it sounds too promising but I have no grounds for such a presumption. I'm not an expert on horns.

"German Physics is a legitimate and highly credible manufacturer who is unlikely to market a product that is utterly without merit."

I would not say that. The $1000 speakers are quite good (similar to design to the Walshes in my system but smaller) and have garnered a nice following. If teh GPs sound as good, then that has merit. They are just 20X as expensive, so not much merit there.

Stthomas, I can assure you that I do more than just say what I read. I read to help learn. I do not discredit anyone or anything without basis. I tend to give most the benefit of the doubt that they have some information of value to share until I determine otherwise.

Best to keep an open mind in general!