I would also hope that you do name products as well as discuss theories and science. I am confident that most uf us can make up our own minds about purchases even with manufacturers input. It's a rare post indeed which doesn't mention a product. I'm guessing that the percentage of posts containing advocacy by sales folks is nonzero. IMHO it's better to hear all opinions.
Can a manufacturer post replies & discussions?
Hi Audiogoners and Moderators,
I am a manufacturer of high end audio accessories. As such, am I allowed (according to Audiogon guidelines) to post responses to questions that pertain to my field of vibration control? I know these forums are not meant to be a form of advertising and I don't intend to promote my products here but I want to make sure that any responses I post do not "cross the line". I expect that I wouldn't be allowed to name any of my products directly. Is that correct? What about discussing, and maybe being critical of, other philosophies of vibration control that are at odds with mine or products that are not executed well? If I would do so I would not discuss any other company's product specifically by name but by the general design pricinples.
I would appreciate any comments or suggestions. Thank you.
Barry Kohan
I am a manufacturer of high end audio accessories. As such, am I allowed (according to Audiogon guidelines) to post responses to questions that pertain to my field of vibration control? I know these forums are not meant to be a form of advertising and I don't intend to promote my products here but I want to make sure that any responses I post do not "cross the line". I expect that I wouldn't be allowed to name any of my products directly. Is that correct? What about discussing, and maybe being critical of, other philosophies of vibration control that are at odds with mine or products that are not executed well? If I would do so I would not discuss any other company's product specifically by name but by the general design pricinples.
I would appreciate any comments or suggestions. Thank you.
Barry Kohan
- ...
- 20 posts total
You can count me in as one whom enjoys these exchanges with MFGs and such. Most have a specialized experience. I certainly don't have that kind of knowledge. Sometimes it gets 'hot' but that brings forth better input. I've seen some MFGs get slammed; some dealers/ sellers need a slam--and it happens. I remember years ago "Mr.Chips" thought he was "Mr.Power" chord.He was in every pc thread for a while. He was just another 'flavour-of the month'--dealer; not a design engineer. I bought 2 of his cords--- Anybody with more experience than I;I enjoy learning from.---Somebody whom just 'sells' stuff-- that's different. |
Barry, Although it may be hard to walk the line you propose, your expertise will be appreciated. Just be prepared to receive back other opinions in conflict with yours. Each Audiogon member has a way of marching to his own drummer, hearing what he hears, regardless of what an ordained expert presents. |
Welcome to audiogon. Considering your consideration here I doubt you will have much trouble in practice. Simply posting ideas in general terms keeps the seas calm enough. What a manufacturer can post, however, apparently has to do with their "Advertising Agreement with Audiogon". |
- 20 posts total