2. analog
  3. 127425-2217

VPI Scout 2 vs. Luxman PD 441

I'm on the fence about just selling my Luxman PD 441 table as I need to upgrade the tonearm from a Denon DA-307 and that seems to be a $1,000+ proposition.
I would replace it with something from VPI and keep my Grado The Reference high output cartridge.  Maybe a Scout 2 with JMW 9 arm?
My question is whether it is worth it for me to upgrade to a better arm for the Luxman or just ditch the whole thing and get a VPI?
Can I even get any $ for the Luxman to soften the blow?
Thanks for any advice.
Brian

bdunne
dgarretson
2,592 posts
 
Don't sell it! I moved through an extensively modified VPI TNT and several vintage DDs to a PD444.  Replace the stock elastomer footers with Stillpoints find a better tonearm. 
Ag insider logo xs@2x
tonykay
1,298 posts
 
I agree. I sold my Luxman PD 444 because I didn't think I needed two arms. I have regretted it since. I would replace the Denon arm. So, to answer your last question, I believe that you could sell the PD 441 to recoup some of the cost of an upgrade. I, for one, would have an interest.
mb1audio02
188 posts
 
" Maybe a Scout 2 with JMW 9 arm?"

That's what I have. I wouldn't hesitate to buy it again. I've never compared it to your current TT, so I really can't say anything definite on that. That said, my guess is that it would be a very nice improvement from what you now have. Also, VPI usually offers a nice selection of upgrades so you're not forced to get a new TT if you want to improve things in the future.
bdunne OP
57 posts
 
For those of you suggesting I keep the Luxman, do I need to spend in the $1,000 range for a better tonearm than the Denon?  A past suggestion has been a Fidelity Research 64S.
dgarretson
2,592 posts
 
Consider a Micro Seiki MS-505(the original version, not a MkII or MkIII) They are $800-$1K on ebay, depending on condition and completeness with accessories and box.  It's a great all round arm and more versatile with modern cartridges than a FR 64S.
More to discover