Need recommendation for a CD player

Sound to me like you have the opportunity to evaluate both approaches in your own system. I encourage you to do so. I also have a computer based system using the Mac Mini however at times insert a CD into my player. The Marantz will provide you that option in addition to possibly supplying a better sounding DAC. 

If you don't need SACD, Yamaha has regular CD player for $299 with a very good review, Music direct sell it..

I build DACs and I could probably ship one to you for $1200 plus the shipping and if you don't like it return it.

Keep us posted- ericruff

The Oppo’s are great but not very good with rebook cd’s as far as I’m concerned. Is the op looking for rebook playback? I'm not bashing Oppo. They're nice but if you want the best in rebook reproduction look elsewhere.