I have the 3A sigs for about a year now and could not be more impressed. I've attended many demo's prior to the purchase and heard a lot of great, and not so great speakers. The one thing that sucked me into Vandersteen was that I just couldn't stop listening to them. Some speakers I raved about imagining, others the level of detail but the 3A's I just listened and enjoyed. To me they are just make you want to listed instead of dissecting the pros/cons. I have an odd shaped room with high ceilings and I can not tell how much proper placement, tilt, toe and contour controls can improve the sound but even right out the box they sounded great....just very enjoyable to listen to with zero fatigue. when that woofer is pushed properly rock music is excellent
|
the comments about value are absurd. Richard is hyper frugal and nothing absolutely nothing makes it into a speaker without adding value. The 3A sig use same tweeter and mid as the vaunted 5a Tyler while sourcing direct to consumer use Scanspeak drivers as do Vandersteen including a patented MID. As you should know Scanspeak has nothing to touch the carbon / balsa drivers at any price.
perhaps you should start a Tyler thread vs. pollute helping the OP
email me a picture of your 5 a carbons as you set them up, who was your dealer?
|
Tomic scroll down and read below Looks like Deepee is already on the Tyler agenda payroll. Look at his glowing Vandy review something had to change! Like you said Tyler is a good box speaker and I have heard them. Id enjoy and invite Comparison Vandersteen 1CIs at $1274 the pair to the 2500 tyler boxes and see what most will leave with Let alone try and play Chris Issac San Fransisco days 515 was just a train, without the Cows mooing. Best JohnnyR
deepee9923 posts01-25-2014 7:52amI've
had my Vandy 5A Carbons for about 18 months now; they replaced my
beloved Maggie IIs which were coupled with an ancient Vandy 2W powered
subwoof. Given the right source material, the 5s just seem to disappear
from the room, leaving only the music. Setting up the high-pass filters
to match your amp's input impedance is a matter of setting a few DIP
switches and takes about a minute to figure out and do. You can spend as
much or as little time as you wish emplacing and angling the speaks for
a single sweet spot to take advantage of Richard's efforts to provide
perfect imaging, or just muscle the things around till they sound right
in your room. Mine are toed-outward about 30 degrees and about 18-inches
from the long wall they're on, and from my off-center listening chair
the imaging is perfect - and nearly as perfect at the other end of a
7-foot couch. As for power, I run a pair of Vacuum Tube Audio M-125
monoblocks (each with four KT-88- 6550-type tubes in push-pull
configuration) and Roy Mottram tube preamps. In triode mode the
monoblocks step down to about 65 watts per side and I am able to rattle
the dishes three houses down the street with cannon-fire on 1812
Overture; however the true joy is hearing the difference between the
"tink" of a cymbal most speakers give you to the "ding" the Vandies
deliver. Agreed with all above posters, it's GIGO. Feed the
Vandersteen 5A Carbons fresh lobster and they'll serve you fresh
lobster. Feed 'em canned tuna and that's what'll come out. They neither
add nor subtract anything from your playback media. Therein their
beauty. Not mentioned by others here, but IMO vital, is that these
wonderful speakers be discreetly bi-wired as the manual recommends. I
was bi-wiring through a single four-conductor Canares cable and was
quite content. One bored afternoon I doubled-up with some extra cable,
nothing fancy, for true bi-wiring and "WHOMP!!" the backside of the
soundstage just fell away. An unbelievable improvement over what I
already thought was perfection. Don't ask my why; it makes no sense
electrically. (I've since upgraded the speaker cabling and connections a
bit, none of that $1,000 a foot crap, but nothing made the improvement
of the magnitude that discrete bi-wiring does, even if you have to use
lamp cord.) One caution if you're going to spend Lamborghini money on
custom cables: Be sure the speaker ends are spades that will fit the
rather smallish connectors on the back of the speaks. For DIY cables,
Audioquest makes a silver spade that fits just right for 10-12 gauge
wire; otherwise you'll likely spend a few hours on a grinding wheel. Bottom
line is: the 5A Carbons have eliminated one baffling and very expensive
variable in the hi-fi equation. They are, to my ear, invisible.
|
I've been hearing several people say as of late that the Vandersteens are overpriced, which I don't agree with as of now, but this is the first time that someone has actually suggested an alternative. I'll have to go listen to Tyler Acoustics. |
+1 regarding the Vandersteen 1Ci. I'm trying to really reconcile why I'd need anything more. I've been considering them for a few years now. Been buying more expensive monitors that I really question whether they are any better than the Vandy 1s. With the Belles integrated or some Quicksilver tubes I'd probably be set for good.
|