Love the Bird songs, and have to say that Shorter is one of my all-time favorites, soulful or not!
Mintzer is very good!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LSImxDNE6jQ
Mintzer is very good!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LSImxDNE6jQ
Jazz for aficionados
Love the Bird songs, and have to say that Shorter is one of my all-time favorites, soulful or not! Mintzer is very good! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LSImxDNE6jQ |
acman , I think you made my point . Shorter was the only guy in his trio that could actually put some heart in that dissonance. Certainly not trying to " dis " you , its just easier to hear when you are about same age as Shorter .Seems to be hard for younger people , which is logical IMO . i.e Gonzalo Rubalcabla , they hear him as a very talented player . I hear him as someone who uses that talent to praise the divine, he himself says as much in interviews . Not in every thing he does , but it's always hanging around . |
Schubert, Thats the thing, I can hear heart/soul from all player in Shorter's band. They have been together for almost 20 years, and are playing in a very advanced style. Their interplay is right up there with Miles great late 60's group, which had Wayne Shorter, not surprisingly, in it. I am not offended by your viewpoint in the least and will ponder on it for awhile. It is always welcome. I also hear what you hear in Gonzalo Rubalcabla. I hear the same with Gregory Porter. Hard to get heard without the talent they have been given and developed. |