New Santana, Lowest Dynamic Range Ever

A criticism that has been leveled at Carlos playing more than once in recent years.


A real shame as they were pure magic when I caught them live back in England in 78 or 79.


But with all that said I personally thought his earlier mini ep release this year , In Search of Mona Lisa was better fare.

Maybe we should start a new thread: New Releases With Good DR.

It would be a very short thread I'm afraid.

It is a hard time to be an audiophile that likes new music. Most of this crap sounds _better_ in the car.

But aren't there albums we must listen to for their music, regardless of DR?

Maybe this Santana release isn't it, but I'm thinking of old U2 and Talking Heads.

@erik_squires "But aren't there albums we must listen to for their music, regardless of DR?"

Sure. In many cases we have no choice. I have a long list of albums/artists whose material stinks in terms of SQ because the DR is so narrow. If you want to listen to _that_ music, you have to deal with poor SQ. That's just the way it is.

And I think it is a crying shame in so many cases.

I'm also suspect of audiophiles who claim such recordings sound good in terms of SQ. I think I am probably very sensitive to it. Even though a lot of other audiophile nuances are beyond me, a highly compressed recording causes fairly quick listening fatigue and it is obvious to me as soon as the music starts.

I am dubious about claims that system and room tuning can fix severe DR compression but I am certain it can help. A recording in the 5-6 DR range can be made listenable but I don't think it can be made 'good' no matter what you do or what your system is capable of.

This might be heresy but I think tweaking with a digital EQ can help. Have no experimented with an actual component EQ but now that there are so many good new artists releasing highly compressed work I am considering getting one. What a pain that it though.

@eric squires Maybe. I buy based on DR, among other things. But generally have no interest in lower DR recordings. Once it goes under 6 or 7 I’m done. Regardless. Maybe only a couple exceptions.

Meaning I have mostly older releases (pre-1995) and a lot of old Targets, Japan releases, Audio Fidelity, AM+, PONO etc.

Just checked my old TH and U2 to the earliest releases. DR is 11-12 avg. for all. But again these are selected for certain qualities including DR.