Shostakovich:
Case in point? Hardly. It is a great symphony!!!
Again, you’re mixing and conflating issues. Did artists live in fear during Stalin’s Russia? Yes, a well documented fact; many left for America. So, what does that have to do with the main argument? Proponent of “the great unwashed” determining the ultimate value in music? Was Stalin the great unwashed? Seems to me he was the elite. Unfortunately, the one with ultimate power. You are confusing thematic content and style with artistic quality. How does any of this relate to do with Miles playing Jazz to an audience?
https://youtu.be/ghj5V5cUo1s
Case in point? Hardly. It is a great symphony!!!
Again, you’re mixing and conflating issues. Did artists live in fear during Stalin’s Russia? Yes, a well documented fact; many left for America. So, what does that have to do with the main argument? Proponent of “the great unwashed” determining the ultimate value in music? Was Stalin the great unwashed? Seems to me he was the elite. Unfortunately, the one with ultimate power. You are confusing thematic content and style with artistic quality. How does any of this relate to do with Miles playing Jazz to an audience?
https://youtu.be/ghj5V5cUo1s