I think many of the mysteries discussed in this thread make it difficult to grasp the unifying issue. Different rooms and different speakers, its extremely complex behavior. ( I swear acoustics is a black art) Is it the speaker or the room? Erik talks about how he doesn't hear much difference with absorption at first reflection zones. Another poster says absorption at first reflection zones is HUGE, big difference. How could they both be true?
I am suspecting the common issue between these two ideas is the speaker dispersion: the wide dispersion having a stronger effect on first reflections, the narrower having less impact on reflection points. It is quite possible we do not know what the mid and/or tweeter dispersion of our speakers really is. If we don't know, we could attribute a lot of audible results to things that may be unrelated. The specs we are given don't come close to revealing this super important info.
Brad
I am suspecting the common issue between these two ideas is the speaker dispersion: the wide dispersion having a stronger effect on first reflections, the narrower having less impact on reflection points. It is quite possible we do not know what the mid and/or tweeter dispersion of our speakers really is. If we don't know, we could attribute a lot of audible results to things that may be unrelated. The specs we are given don't come close to revealing this super important info.
Brad