Which speakers did you find bright, fatiguing or just disappointing in some way?


OK, controversial subject but it needs asked. I'm curious for your experiences, mainly in your home, not a dealer and esp. not a show demo
greg7
WOW, came here to add to the TOPIC, but I see it turned into some type of argumentative discussion that the moderator could not seem to 'reel in'.   But I would like to add............

Being a Klipschorn owner for 14 years which I enjoyed, I decided to try one of their Reference Premier towers.  So, bought the Klipsch flagship RP-280F models.  Liked them at first, but after a few months, I realized that the titanium, horn loaded tweeter was a bit too 'forward' to my liking.  I bought a quality pair of L-PADS and installed them using the bi-amp inputs to the tweeters.

Running the control to it's midpoint really helped.  But, after a time, I decided that it was just a bandaid and decided to do a complete departure from horns, cones and domes.  So, bought a completely new system.  Martin Logan eStats (after a long audition at my local brick and mortar audio dealer), and an amp and preamp of John Curl design.  If anything, the electrostats are a bit on the warm side, however, at 91 DB efficient, they have plenty of dynamic range, and in NO WAY do they fatigue the ears.  Keep in mind, the cross over is at 380 Hz. so the panel covers a wide range before the bass module comes into play. 

And the concerns about the blending of the two drivers an issue?,  those days are over with the latest models.   I DID just add the Dynamo 1600X to add the bottom octave below 35Hz.

So, there is my honest story.
I'm struck that this thread exploded in all the tedious controversy & name-calling so many threads do. WTF?

It's a pretty straightforward topic by OP. Here's my answer:

-- in the mid-'80s when Infinity was coming on like gangbusters, I bought one of their cheaper floorstanders w/planar tweeter & a 10" polypropylene woofer. Not only was this thing brighter than hell, but that woofer audibly "bounced" like a medicine ball hitting a trampoline. Awful speakers

-- and a couple years ago, in the dying twilight of my attempts to use powered monitors for music. I got a pair of Yamaha HS7 powered monitors modded by ZenPro. I burned them in faithfully, then put them in the desktop system where they sounded like ass immediately & forever. I didn't last 2 days--yanked 'em out & put back in whatever I had previously.

No amount of money paid is worth sonic suffering after...
ProAc are wonderful. Their true ribbon tweeter is sublime. Harbeths are easy to listen to but can be a bit boring, but certainly listenable. BTW the ML and a few others use the Heil AMT ( Air Motion Transformer) I’ve always found it a bit bright. Raidho are nice. Magico but very revealing and need the right everything to get them to sing. 
I found JM LAB Focal Stella Utopia upfront and bright. Head ached after 20 minutes every time.  Couldn’t be the amp Pass
Labs XA 100.8.