They think that human ears are inferior to measuring tools...They use the limits of their tools and project it on the human ears like if it was only an external material tool... They claim, blinded with their parameters coming from ONE dimension only that we cannot hear - 200 Db signal noise ratio for example... They are not even wrong...
They dont know that "music" dont exist in the world.... Only sounds...
It is consciousness creation called "art"...
What we hear in music and speech cannot be reduced to all measures...It can be correlated yes , reduced never...This is Science....This is the basis of good design...
But ultimately what is there to be measured, the "sounds" are TRANSFORMED by the act of hearing them in something, music or speech, which we can understand but cannot totally measured on all his dimensions simultaneously like the brain did it... We created also speech when speaking or music when playing an instrument, which convey the soul in an intricate way which cannot be understood WITHOUT a translation by the soul of the listener... There is nothing more to measure, the essential is not there to be measured but to be understood by the will and heart and not only the mind...Shannon information theory is not a poem, the equations live on a scale which is not the same scale of meaning than a poem....
One day some robot will say to me that he can think and some will believe it...
I will never believe it because to think we need to be connected to all the universe at once or to the source of meaning ....
And by mathematical definition an A. I. is a disconnected tools...Save for cultist and superstitious mind like transhumanism zealots whatever sophisticated they are....
Like migrating birds navigating earth, human body perceive with way more than the external limited tools in one dimension and limited parameters....The human body is itself an integrated measuring set of tools connected to many dimensions exceeding any of our normal external tools...
«Our tools never dreams»-Groucho Marx 🤓
They dont know that "music" dont exist in the world.... Only sounds...
It is consciousness creation called "art"...
What we hear in music and speech cannot be reduced to all measures...It can be correlated yes , reduced never...This is Science....This is the basis of good design...
But ultimately what is there to be measured, the "sounds" are TRANSFORMED by the act of hearing them in something, music or speech, which we can understand but cannot totally measured on all his dimensions simultaneously like the brain did it... We created also speech when speaking or music when playing an instrument, which convey the soul in an intricate way which cannot be understood WITHOUT a translation by the soul of the listener... There is nothing more to measure, the essential is not there to be measured but to be understood by the will and heart and not only the mind...Shannon information theory is not a poem, the equations live on a scale which is not the same scale of meaning than a poem....
One day some robot will say to me that he can think and some will believe it...
I will never believe it because to think we need to be connected to all the universe at once or to the source of meaning ....
And by mathematical definition an A. I. is a disconnected tools...Save for cultist and superstitious mind like transhumanism zealots whatever sophisticated they are....
Like migrating birds navigating earth, human body perceive with way more than the external limited tools in one dimension and limited parameters....The human body is itself an integrated measuring set of tools connected to many dimensions exceeding any of our normal external tools...
«Our tools never dreams»-Groucho Marx 🤓