2. digital
  3. 167551-138745

SLOT LOADING CD MECHANISMS - DO THE DAMAGE CD'S?

Of recent, I have been considering the purchase of a new CD transport (no DAC). There are several that have caught my attention; - - one in particular is made by AUDIOLAB. The one factor that leaves me "hanging", conceptually speaking, is the fact that AUDIOLAB exclusively uses "slot loading" CD mechanisms.
I have owned a couple of good quality CD players employing this type mechanism, and in both cases, eventually discovered marring to the playing surface of the CD. I am fanatic about proper preservation of CD playing surfaces. I certainly don’t want more CD’s ending up in the garbage can. (and I don’t like polishing, making a bad situation, worse !)

In turn, I have read many articles and customer reports complaining of the same issue. I consider AUDIOLAB products to be of a quality and performance level that leaves me somewhat dumbfounded as to why they would employ the use of a questionable mechanism that has so many historic issues.
So, what have they done that would be any different than other companies using this concept? I can’t imagine that they would invest the R&D money to develop their own proprietary mechanism.
Anyone out there that can validify the credibility (or lack of) AUDIOLAB’S use of "slot loading ?. Direct experience would help the most.
128x128axpert
glennewdick's avatar
glennewdick
1,692 posts
 
I think the reality of the reduction of CD-CDR etc. for anything even computer work has practically gone or soon to be gone. The advent of USB drives for example seems to have killed the CDR for computer use.

DND (Department of National Defense, Canada) has all but removed all CD drives from their computers for example.

Same goes for CD Drives just not many making them anymore so the few manufacturers that are making CD players and CD transports are all using one of the few CD drives still available from the OEM’s.

This is why I always recommend to move to a storage medial like a NAS or a device like the BlueSound vault and store the CD’s for backup.

Alternatively there’s still quite a few multi disk transports out there, (and a few CD players and transports, but less every year). then just add a good DAC.

Buying a used CD player and/or transport is something i avoid unless I know there's parts (CD Drives) still available. 
fuzztone's avatar
fuzztone
5,631 posts
 
Not so. The Stream Unlimited Pro 8 drive is new from the ground up, top load. As found in the Gryphon Ethos. Yes Mr. pair of noid, there are parts available. This drive is soooo much better than my 4 year old NAD was. AND you don’t have to wait for the mechanism to respond. Or not.
It takes 5 seconds to load a disc and 3 more to read in the TOC.
Yes I listen to 90% files but most music sounds better on this CDT, with the same DAC.
fuzztone's avatar
fuzztone
5,631 posts
 
https://www.project-audio.com/en/product/cd-box-rs2-t/
georgehifi's avatar
georgehifi
10,312 posts
 

Slot loaders are usually cheap Chinese transports so are their lasers, and are used in cars and computers.

Just look at what happens to your CD’s that were used in the car, the slot loaders do put many fine scratches across the CD’s.

Tray load or top load the better way for quality transports, and many are Philips, Sony, Teac, Sanyo etc etc

Cheers George
axpert's avatar
axpert OP
124 posts
 
Thanks "FUZZTONE". I am aware of the PRO-JECT piece. Very interesting, but by the time I pair it up with a respectable performing high performance DAC, the total will be beyond my budget spectrum. The AUDIOLAB piece is an excellent performer in it's (my) price class.. But the loading mechanism issue lingers. The suggestion of making "throw away copies" is just not my style. Guess I am still hoping to hear from someone that has an AUDIOLAB transport. Nothing like "hands on" experience.
More to discover