Dynaudio vs Focal

How would you compare Scala and Temptation for a small to medium room that has thick carpet/curtain etc? Which is more tolerant of different rooms? Compare in the areas of micro detail, clarity, liveliness/excitement, brightness, transparency, soundstage and bass suitability. Which is easier to drive and control with a solid state amplifier ? How much power brings them to life ?

HAving heard both lines though not in a/b comparison, I suspect they both can deliver top notch sound when set up properly in the right room. I like both very much and could probably live with either. Personal preference and synergy with the rest of the system will likely be the key determining factors in deciding between the two.

I think of Focal sound in a similar vein as their French brethren Triangle line, call it the "French" sound, very fast, detailed, and with a tonal balance perhaps slightly more tipped towards the high end.

The Dynaudio sound is articulate and well integrated top to bottom and the tonal balance more towards the warm side.

I am not convinced that Focal is as inherently articulate in teh bass as Dynaudio in general, but I could be wrong there.

per mapman and elvukai, i've gotta believe the focals can be top performers when paired with the right room and equipment. what was odd about my hearing of the maestros was that they were being driven by a monstrous megabuck (500w?) rowland amp in a dedicated, treated listening room--this wasn't like hearing something driven by a $300 avr at best buy. i do think that there are probably other great speakers in the same class, say revel salon or vandersteen 7, which are easier to drive and place. in any event, if you're gonna drop this kind of dough, you'll want to get an in-home, no-risk trial to make sure your choice will work for your particular setup.

Thanks to all for the feedback so far!
Elviukai, I would really like your feedback on my last post. I have no idea of how to email anyone anymore on this site.

"I have no idea of how to email anyone anymore on this site.”

Me too. Is that function still available?