OP -
If you want a true home theater experience it’s easily doable and you won’t duplicate it with a 2 channel set up no matter how hard you try. That said, if you have a great sub set up integrated with your 2 channel set up, you may be really happy with it for movie / TV watching. Would it match a true Home Theater set up, nah, not even close.
Are the comments on a center channel correct, they are. Truth is a high percentage of a movie soundtrack mix is played through the center channel, mostly due to dialogue dominating the mix. Center channels are flawed inherently as they were designed to fit a set up without being in the way of the screen. All that said, most of what the center channel will play is dialogue - a decent center will do all you need, it won’t be anywhere near the same league as a speaker you’d use for your 2 channel listening, but it will do the job intended and do it well. This assumes the Center is used in a true Home Theater set up. If you went the route of 2 fronts and a center only, everyone is absolutely correct that you should skip the center.
The invention of HT Bypass and really stellar HT room correction will blend mismatched speakers and even amplification extremely well. Adding gear the right way will have zero impact on your 2 channel set up. In fact, you won’t even have to turn on your Home Theater Receiver / Processor. I love both, I wouldn’t give up either when the gear / Technolodgy exists to deliver both with little to no compromise. Again, if you integrate HT Bypass correctly, keep your beloved 2 channel speakers, when you listen to 2 channel, you never even turn on your Home Theater gear, how does that impact your 2 channel…. The only tricky part can be sub integration with both, but that’s easily tackled if you have subs that allow you to save multiple set ups, one for movies, one for music.
I’ve had 5 Home Theater processor’s / receivers, none have come close to a dedicated 2 channel set up for music, either a pre / amp set up or integrated set up. That said, running 2 channel with Subs doesn’t hold a candle to the movie watching experience with a HT set up. If you love that part of the movie watching experience you owe it to yourself to have both, period. Sharing the same room, front speakers is more than doable.
Most that participate in this forum are heavily focused on 2 channel HiFi and that makes perfect sense. Home Theater for most is a distant second and for some reason is always seen as a massive threat to a 2 channel set up. Very similar to back in the day when some 2 channel purest would avoid sub woofer integration with 2 channel at all costs. If you went on a Hime Theater / AV forum, you’d get a heavy lean toward HT. I happen to love both and share the same passion for both equally, seems to be unique as most really lean one way or the other.