2. digital
  3. 175130-170859

Is a cheaper DAC + Reclocker better than just an expensive DAC?

Hi All,

I'm still in my DAC dilemma phase, and have come across this situation, is a cheaper DAC + Reclocker better than just an expensive DAC?  The basis for this is the below Gustard example.  Also, i've read a review that commented on the X26 being further improved when a reclocker was added.

Gustard U18 reclocker ($635 CAD) + Gustard X18 ($952 CAD) = $1,587 CAD

OR

Gustard X26 = $1,907 CAD

 

So if i wanted to:

- have a mind-blowing DAC experience (stepping up from my Khadas Tone Board DAC)

-not have any regrets

- extinguish any upgrade fever

- make girls like me...

 

...is it a general rule that a DAC+reclocker will ususally sound better than a standalone more expensive DAC, and so i should pursue this route?

Does anyone have any amazing examples of cheaper DACs, that when coupled with a reclocker, elevate the combo into the really acoustically high-end and detailed areas of the hobby?

 

fai_v
soix
10,348 posts
 

Good question. BTW, I love hearing from women in our hobby — far too rare IMHO. And a Canadian, even better (I’m a hockey player). Anyway, I think I may have a solution for both your questions, and one you didn’t even ask. Agree with others to get the better DAC, but with your budget I’d suggest stepping up to a Denafrips Pontus ll, but if that’s out of your budget the Musician Pegasus would be a good substitute (not sure how prices translate from US$ to CAD these days). I have the Pegasus and like it a lot. You can read good reviews of these DACs and the Gustard X26 at soundnews.net. They’re all great, so just go by which gets closest to the sound qualities you’re looking for and is within budget.

Now, for the bonus, your very noisy computer is much more of a problem than reclocking. But, for around $140USD you can get an iFi Purifier 3 that will importantly help reduce the noise from your computer but will also work as a reclocker. So you can have your cake and eat it too! Hope this helps, and best of luck!

mahler123
3,648 posts
 

OP

  I tried the route you went, and the answer is “No”

geof3
1,129 posts
 

Rarely are there any “shortcuts” in this game…

erik_squires
16,892 posts
 

As several modern DAC makers have pointed out, you need the clock as physically close to the DAC chip as possible.  An external clock can't be as accurate, but in professional uses may be needed.

The other issue is, USB has the highest bandwidth, so not sure what use USB in to S/PDIF out is useful.

The one big benefit I see of the U18 is something which SHOULD be in every single DAC but isn't, which is galvanic isolation of every metal input, including USB.

markkpa
14 posts
 

Well...I would have given you the same advice 6 months ago - buy the best single dac unit you can afford.  But, now that I've completed my own digital front-end upgrade, I would recommend buying the best DAC you can afford AND add a reclocker.

In my case, I bought two DAC's to compare side-by-side.  I sold the Gustard x26 Pro and kept a cheaper AliExpress DC500 (dual AKM4499EQ's) because it sounded better.  And then the fun started.  I upgraded two MUSES03 opamps with discrete opamps: https://www.ebay.com/itm/253836156827.  I bought an AF200 reclocker with CCHD-957 Crystek oscillators: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32984221035.html?spm=a2g0o.store_pc_allProduct.8148356.2.2ec7157d9cysMu.  I bought linear power supply for the AF200 reclocker: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005001786989766.html?spm=a2g0o.order_list.0.0.21ef1802ZGWgdz.  I'm using a high quality AES/EBU cable between the DC500 DAC and the AF200 reclocker.  I kept my usb cable short & removed ferrite rings.  The results were astonishing - there's no way a $900.00 Chinese DAC should sound this good - but it does (after spending an additional $450.00 on the upgrades).  One last thing - do not use any digital attenuation on your DAC!

 

More to discover