Atma-Sphere M60 monoblocks + ML ESL 11 = Inferior combo


Hi guys,

Today I borrowed home a pair of pure OTL-Tube M60 mononblocks to combine with my ML ESL 11s (which base are partially driven by a Class-D amplifer of 275 watts) with very poor results. Unfortunately, although the M60s where only to cater for the diaphragm panels (at least in theory), when combined with the speakers, the soundstage collapsed, vocals felt muffled and absent deep into the sound picture, almost hidden away, and the base went out of control (got larger and louder in a negative way). I also lost details. The Monos are a pair of brand new demos and shined this morning together with a pair of smaller Vivid monitors.

My current SS - a Bryston 4B3 delivers so much better combined with the ML ESL 11s. Someone that can explain what I did just experience? I thought that OTL tubes and High sensitive Martin Logans of todays generation where to be a marriage in heaven.

Kind regards 

 

  

128x128andy_wonderwall

Too bad more audiophiles don’t investigate the suggestion of @ticat, myself, and a few others, and look into the Eminent Technology LFT-8b. A planar-magnetic loudspeaker, in some ways very much like the Magnepan, but in other ways dissimilar.

The LFT-8b is more like an electrostatic than are Maggies, in both sound and power amp appropriateness. No offense to either Magnepan or owners of their outstanding loudspeakers (I have owned four pair, one currently). But if you want a planar loudspeaker that will mate with the Atma-Sphere M-60 (or generally any tube amp), the LFT-8b is a great option. It’s modulus-of-impedance is a very even 8 ohms, the p-m panel itself (which sits atop a sealed 8" dynamic woofer for the reproduction of 180Hz down, via a second set of binding posts) an almost ruler-flat 11 ohm load, ideal for all tube amps, none more so than an OTL such as the Atma-Spheres (with which I am very familiar, having used a pair of M-60’s with my QUAD ESL’s, a/k/a 57’s).

Despite very positive reviews in The Absolute Sound, Hi-Fi Choice, Hi-Fi World, Hi-Fi Pig, Positive feedback, and from Harry Weisfeld of VPI (who declared the LFT-8b to provide the best midrange reproduction of any loudspeaker he has ever heard. The ET LFT driver reproduces 180Hz to 10kHz, with NO CROSSOVER!), U.S.A. audiophiles continue to ignore the best value loudspeaker (imo) of any on the market.

Part of that blame can be attributed to the low number of Eminent Technology dealers (which pales in comparison to those of Magnepan), but E-T will ship you a pair to audition in your system. Some E-T owners prefer the LFT-8b to not only the Magnepan MG-1.7i (I have heard both---it’s not even close), but also the MG3.7i, which retails for more than twice the price of the LFT-8b.

I expect this post will be ignored as have been all like it in the past. It’s your loss, not mine ;-) .

@decooney

Thanks for good advice. And yes. Both types of amplification, stellar in their own way. If I ever would have the budget to have a smaller separate system the M60s would be on the list together with speakers suited for the technology. But for the moment I am focusing on a large scale system with the ML´s 11s as foundation, (alternative ever the larger 13s one day). So I need to adopt suiting amplification. The 4B3 is an excellent partner! That SS has a lush sweet bold powerful sound together with the MLs for sure. Could definitely be my end game. But what would this hobby be without setting new personal frontiers? Another mountain to climb :-)? I am lucky to have a dealer that are willing to borrow me MBL N15s monoblocks so that I can compare different technologies on the MLs.

@bdp24

Thanks for advice. 

These speakers sounds interesting. Will not break the bank either. 

Its a shame no dealer in Sweden carries them. Would be interesting to listen to them to see how they compete (in my ears) to a pair of large MLs.

KR

@andy_wonderwall have you tried pairing up a really good tube preamp in front of your Bryston 4B3 amplifier?  If not, this can yield another very nice result too.  What  preamp are you using with your Atma M60 mono tube amps now?

@andy_wonderwall -

' I am lucky to have a dealer that are willing to borrow me MBL N15s monoblocks so that I can compare different technologies on the MLs'.

 

The MBL's should be able to drive just about anything, but if I were to get them, I would just get a pair of Radialstrahler's.

Bob