Is it worth upgrading a CD player?


I’ve had my Marantz CD6002 for around 14 years and it’s still going strong. I have it connected to an Audiolab M-DAC+ and play via my Rega amp. I’m mostly vinyl but have started to playvmy CD’s more recently and wondered whether upgrading the CD player would be worth it or not, given the fact it’s played via a dedicated DAC. Am I right in thinking there would be little noticeable improvement?

side22olto

Just not a fan of the transport/dac solution any more for playing CD’s. If I have 2 or 3 sources connected to the same dac or use it double duty as a preamp, fine. But with a collection of 1000 CD’s worth it to me to upgrade to a one and done solution where the transport/dac.are in a single unit.

Black Ice 1 box tube based solution that will also stream wireless via apple airplay or DLNA:

solid state Marantz unit that will also stream via USB:

 

I forgot to mention my cd collection is ripped to an external drive and then either streamed through the house via Sonos or played directly to the DAC via a USB cable from a Mac. I still manage the music library using iTunes.

If you have the cash to float and are not locked in on itunes, pick up the Bryston BDP Pi on here for ~$550.  Then attach the your ripped storage to it via USB and hook the Pi to your DAC.   The Pi will also stream Tidal or Qobuz up to 24/196 if you have wired internet to it in some fashion.   You can even hook external DVD player to Pi and rip CDs directly to storage.    The web interface is spartan and frustrating to some but the SQ is good.  Pi easily sold if you dont like it.   If you got even more cash look at the BDP -2 or 3. 

@carlsbad 100% agree the DAC is way more pivotal in its roll in the digital audio chain. Transport with a high performing DAC that will also benefit streaming is the way to go. 

Just upgraded to a LessLoss DAC with Firewire 640X and will be adding additional 640X's to my system. Outstanding products from Switzerland. 

LessLoss Power Distributor | Atelier 13 Audio (atelier13-usa.com)

 

 

 

LessLoss Echo's End R-2R DAC| Atelier 13 Audio (atelier13-usa.com)

I have had the Marantz CD6002 for about 10 years. I upgraded everything in the last 3 years but never for once was unhappy with the CD player. I think it would be very hard to gain anything by replacing it (in my "budget", low-end system). I compared it to streaming and vinyl, same songs, and - again - with my components, all three sources were profoundly different but not necessarily better/worse. Some music sound best on CDs, mostly certain genre and decade - to my ears.

 

btw what speakers did you end up with?

 

As posted by @newbee,

"there is considerable difference between a CD transport (what you are using your Marantz as) and dedicated transports." 

I am hearing more lately about the quality of CDs played through a dedicated transport being sonically better than, or at least equal to, high level streaming equipment.  I have a couple of pretty good DACs here and the manufacturer of those DACs believes CDs played through a good quality transport sound better than streamed audio (and that manufacturer makes a streamer!).   

I have heard good things about the Audiolab CDT6000 transport discussed in this thread.  If you can afford another level up, the Jay's Audio CDT2-MK3 or their flagship CDT3-MK3 have a strong following. I haven't pulled the trigger on a transport because I have so far doubted that the delta between the sound quality from my streamer/server and that provided by a transport playing physical CDs would be large enough to outweigh the convenience of streaming, at least for me.