Here we go again with the cleaning fetish. Last iteration was only a month or two back.
Once again, I say I rarely hear surface noise on my records. If I do, I clean on my Nitty Gritty I have had for 40+ years now. Then I put the disc in a new Nagaoka inner, so I know it's been cleaned. I have cleaned perhaps 15-20% of my 4,000 odd collection, judging by the number of new sleeves I have bought.. I can only recollect VERY few times I have heard noise again on a record I have cleaned, so re-cleaning is very rare.
So. How much noise do people hear?
It might be suggested that failing to clean a record before playing it allows deposits to cause wear on the LP in play (or on the stylus). Well, with some discs in my collection 60+ years I have not heard this. Nor do my stylii wear prematurely; indeed with my parallel tracking arm running typically at 2.5g (a bit less for the van den Huls) they mostly outlast constructor's life estimates.
There are those here who clean every record before play. I regard this as truly obsessive behaviour, but I wonder if repeated cleaning (especially wet cleaning and brush/pad contact cleaning) causes damage?