Turntable recommendation

If you want new with warranty a Schiit Mani (phono preamp) and a Rega P1 (it comes with a decent cartridge) would run around $750.

I listened to the P1 last year when I was demoing a pair of speakers and liked the sound through a Rega integrated/phono amp.

The Mani is positively reviewed.

Fluance decks (less expensive than Rega P1) seem to be well received, but they lack VTA adjustment which would make them a no-go for me (others don't seem to mind).

DeKay

U-turn audio makes reasonably priced turntables that always get good reviews.

As someone who listens to 95% or more vinyl, I have to say that if you’re currently used to streaming and CD, unless you’re committed to a significant investment I think you’re setting yourself up for a disappointment.  Vinyl on a budget is pretty much an oxymoron today.  That said, vinyl can also become an obsession and provide a musical experience like no other (IMHO), but it does come at a steep price.  Best of luck to you whatever path you choose!

Thank you all. Food for thought and some great choices. We'll see where it leads.

Under $500 is not worth it, closer to $1K to start in my opinion. I'd suggest one of the Rega models also, multiple price ranges, they can come complete with a decent cartridge, so no fiddling with set up. Their whole line gets great reviews. Easy to resell if you get into serious record playing/collecting, it's also a good match for your current system or even if you upgrade a bit. 

I would agree that most of the Technics tables are a good choice also. I have owned them in the past. I own a small record collection (100 new and used) and own a Rega P6 with their installed cartridge. 

I disagree with those discouraging you. True, you may not use it much, I use my table maybe 2-3 times a week, but enjoy spinning and buying albums none-the-less.