Did Amir Change Your Mind About Anything?


It’s easy to make snide remarks like “yes- I do the opposite of what he says.”  And in some respects I agree, but if you do that, this is just going to be taken down. So I’m asking a serious question. Has ASR actually changed your opinion on anything?  For me, I would say 2 things. I am a conservatory-trained musician and I do trust my ears. But ASR has reminded me to double check my opinions on a piece of gear to make sure I’m not imagining improvements. Not to get into double blind testing, but just to keep in mind that the brain can be fooled and make doubly sure that I’m hearing what I think I’m hearing. The second is power conditioning. I went from an expensive box back to my wiremold and I really don’t think I can hear a difference. I think that now that I understand the engineering behind AC use in an audio component, I am not convinced that power conditioning affects the component output. I think. 
So please resist the urge to pile on. I think this could be a worthwhile discussion if that’s possible anymore. I hope it is. 

chayro

😊

i dont understand the GARP reaction ....Posting a definition can be useful... No ?

If you have a better definition of "stupidity" than this Italian economist, please enlighten us...

 

In a philosophical note, this definition remind me of the definition given in the form of a prayer by Christ : " Then Jesus said, ’Father, forgive them; for they do not know what they are doing. ’

Then observe that the Italian economist definition is the same definition given by Christ on the cross, speaking of people doing something helpful to no one and not even to themselves, and doing something detrimental to others and to themselves too , if we think about it...

"Idiots" dont know what they are doing basically...

I am astonished by the convergence between these two minds, the Christ and Cipolla... Are  you not  either ?

It will be hard  in my opinion, to improve on Cipolla definition of stupidity as described in a shortest way by Christ before him ...if someone can improve on this definition i want to listen to him ?

The book is free and in open source by the way...

i apologize , i like philosophy too much...

And sometimes something must be said in a clear way...

Thanks...

 

 

 

Now going back to Amir,

he does only his job as a hobby...

And it is useful...( i dont like though some objectivist rude behaviour at all , Amir on the other hand is polite by the way)

 

Myself i dont focus on gear as marketing do in audio and as Amir analyse in his own way...it is certainly useful to read other opinion...

 

I myself  focus on acoustic and psycho-acoustic...Because it is relatively easy to pick basically good gear anyway, but way more difficult to figure out acoustic...And room acoustic impact at least on the same level than the most beneficial gear upgrade at high cost...

If someone can demonstrate to me that the heart of audio is not psycho-acoustic ... I bet i will quit audiogon...

 

😁😊

 

Noel Lee with his clever marketing of his Monster Cable brand started the high-end wire business back in 1976. Before that everybody used gray Switchcraft IC's and Radio Shack zip cord. Nobody complained! Mr.Lee learned that it was possible to sell a fantasy without engineering credibility to the masses - and become rich in the process! Soon others took notice of Monster's success and the race was on to market wire to the naive, eschewing engineering rationale for "golden ear" fantasy and pseudoscience!

If this isn't the most blatant example of hucksterism then I don't know what is: Jay's Audio Lab's touting of the Transparent $80K "tuned"  speaker cable - that looks like an anaconda snake after a large meal! Maybe some owner can lend a pair to Amir for testing?

@amir_asr I'm sorry you feel that way; the fallacious comment that is

Just for some context, I returned to HiFi following a 25 years or so hiatus. There were a couple of reasons for doing so. I came back in 2021 once local dealerships reopened, as this was in the midst of the pandemic.

I work in the UK's National Health Service (NHS), working in a large Mental Health Trust in  my local region. In the Summer of 2020, at the most impactful (scary) period of the COVID pandemic, I was diagnosed with a rare blood condition (basically a blood cancer) only curable via bone marrow transplant, but mitigated by certain meds.

From a sense of duty to the NHS and my little corner of it, managing 1500 people and being co-responsible for clinical staffing in our mental health wards, I carried on working. By the early Summer of 2021, the stress levels for all of us working in the NHS had reached critical levels, affecting my own and my immediate team's mental health. I needed some kind of distraction or release, hence my decision to jump back in to the hobby. 

Music has always been a passion since early childhood; in my younger years I was a singer/song writer, sound engineer, venue manager, had a small band management company and organized small music festivals. So being too old for these activities, plus being committed to my regular job, I decided to distract myself from my condition and workplace stress, which was the most upsetting.

Many people died during worst of the pandemic; staff, patients, colleagues and their families, so being able to finish work for the day, kick back and lose myself in my music through my hastily put together system was an excellent,very welcome distraction from the carnage occurring all around me; extremely therapeutic and cathartic.

Apart from the actual virus having now dissipated to a large degree, the aftermath it left within the NHS has been disastrous for staffing; my job is to perform damage limitation. Basically the same stress, but without the Spectre of the virus hanging over our heads.

So you see, when I fallaciously sit down, kick back, throw some tunes on, I'm not really thinking graphs, charts, measurements, or how I can be saved from nasty audio manufacturers. I'm just trying to keep my sh*t together so I can get up the next day and do what I need to do for my NHS Trust, for my team, colleagues and most importantly, the patients under our care.

I wish I had nothing else to think about other than sitting around measuring bits of hifi, but my sense of public duty, and service to the public under our collective care, for me is part of my belief system, hence where I work.

As I started the post; I'm sorry you feel the way you do re: fallacious comment, but from where I'm standing, in the greater scheme of things and the real world issues I face every single day, both personally and professionally, how I listen to music; the stress relief it brings, the joy it brings, it's therapeutic value I benefit from ......priceless!

Good luck, Amir