About four years ago I worked for Magnolia at Best Buy and got to hear pricey Mac electronics paired with KEF Blades in a dedicated room just for that system. I’d heard the Blades before at shows and found them to be very neutral and natural-sounding transducers, but the Mac gear made the Blades sound like mush with my audiophile demo material that I know very well. It was overly warm and the top end was veiled and rolled off and sounded nowhere near as good as what I heard at shows. Very disappointing. Maybe the Mac sound signature has changed over the past four years, but I kinda doubt it and would approach with caution. Just my experience FWIW.
Seeking Honest Opinions: Your Experience with McIntosh Audio Gear
I'm reaching out to this knowledgeable community to gather some honest feedback and personal experiences regarding McIntosh audio equipment. As many of you know, McIntosh has a storied reputation in the high-end audio world, known for their distinctive blue meters, impeccable build quality, and, of course, their sonic performance.
Whether you've had McIntosh gear in your setup for years or had the chance to experience it in some capacity, I'm curious to hear about your encounters. Specifically, I'm interested in:
- Sound Quality: How would you describe the sound signature of McIntosh gear? Do you find it warm, neutral, or something else entirely?
- Build Quality and Design: McIntosh is renowned for its craftsmanship. Has their build quality lived up to your expectations?
- Value for Money: Considering the premium investment McIntosh demands, do you believe the performance and satisfaction derived justify the price?
- Customer Service and Support: Have you had any experiences dealing with McIntosh's customer service? If so, how would you rate their support?
- Overall Experience: Would you recommend McIntosh to fellow audio enthusiasts? Why or why not?
Your candid opinions and personal stories will be invaluable, especially for those considering making a significant investment in their audio setup. McIntosh has a dedicated following, but every listener's ears and preferences are unique. Let's shed some light on the real-world experiences behind the brand's prestige.
Looking forward to your insights and honest opinions!
- ...
- 72 posts total
i haven't listened critically to mac gear since the 2010s, and i do recall it sounding warmish/mellow at the high end--i can't opine as to sq of their current stuff. i will say, per @glennewdick above, that its resale value is off the charts--i don't know any other brand that comes close. which on a certain level makes it a very good value, since you can always resell what you don't like, often at a premium. |
I have had many Mac pieces through the years integrated Separates and Tubes. have been very impressive. I would say get a preamp if you are going to use a MC cart. |
Can't beat MAC on price/value ratio nor for resale and service. Sonics and and build quality can be bettered but only by EXPENSIVE stuff like VAC or Boulder etc. I recently heard the top of the line preamp and it is one of the best preamps I've heard including price-no-object competitors, if you were looking right now that preamp would be near the top of my recommended audition list. FYI I own Gryphon electronics. |
Macintosh is a well respected and loved company by many folks. Their equipment is very well made, looks cool, and retains its value well. It is not remotely neutral sounding. It is very heavy on the midrange and bass and is excellent for systems designed primarily for rock music… to thunder and hit your chest with bass. But not to come across as harsh… hence extended midrange. But it lacks detail. I consider it to be the muscle car in the audio world.
I have multiple times over the last decades decided I loved the look so much I was going to invest. I would go to the dealer and audition whatever the latest was. Each time, I would within seconds be so disappointed with the sound quality. No nuance or detail of a natural sounding soundscape. Lacks sophistication and detail. I have a dealer / friend that carries it now. I frequently it is playing. A few years ago he was excited to say that, they had really improved and have a more well balanced sound. I got very enthusiastic. It took ten seconds of listening for disappointment to overcome me. This does not mean you will have the same reaction. As I said, many people love the sound. It has unique strengths. It does what it does really well. Let me reiterate… you put this stuff with some big B&W speakers and it does rock as best as it can be done and Blues You are just engulfed. With the accentuated bass and mid-range you can turn it up loud without the treble being uncomfortable. Great sound for this music. But for jazz, classical, etc. it really lacks the finesse, nuance and balance.
Do not think I am someone that is into systems that scrape details… I am not at all. I want natural, musical sound reproduction, with details in proper proportion… and especially musicality. With over ten years of 7th row center at the symphony and another ten years finding every opportunity to train my ears to what real venues music sounds like, I really do not like “the high end sound” of overly trebly and bassy sound so that triangles and cymbals become solo instruments and the guy plying the cello that moves his foot sticks out. Hence I slowly zeroed in on the equipment I have to be faithful to natural sound and make all music sound great… yet be forgiving.
|
- 72 posts total