DCS Sending Legal Notice To Reviewer (Golden Sound) Over an Old Review of Their Bartok DAC

This whole fiasco is mind boggling.  The fact that DCS shut down any comments as soon as they posted the two comments that are highlighted in this thread tells me all I need to know about them.  Amazing watching business owners use social media to drive two audio companies potentially in the ground in just 6 months.

libel laws are  tricky. to my understanding,  you can't be liable merely for stating an opinion (an opinion being  a belief or viewpoint which may be supported by reason or evidence, but which cannot be proven true or false through evidence). however, merely framing a  statement as an opinion doesn't automatically protect it--if the statement includes or implies the existence of defamatory facts it could be actionable. thus, merely stating that "in my opinion, this dac sounds bad" is protected, but stating that "in my opinion this dac sounds bad because it contains radioactive materials and was assembled by child slave laborers" probably isn't.

looking at this cameron's review, i'd argue that it's classic protected, subjective opinion--even to the extent his opinions are based on (allegedly) false factual assumptions, there's no reason to believe that he knew the assumptions were false, or that said assumptions were defamatory in the sense of maligning dcs. to the larger point, i fully agree that dcs's hissy fit was a remarkably ill-advised, self-inflicted wound--consumers remember this stuff.

loomisjohnson

libel laws are tricky. to my understanding ...

Libel laws vary greatly by nation, and supposedly (according to @audio_phool) the companies involved here aren’t U.S.-based. Still, DCS behaved pretty poorly here before finally apologizing, and the YouTuber uses it all for clicks.

I don’t believe that DCS is being “driven to the ground” and (having some exposure to the company) do believe David’s explanation that the DCS USA employee acted independently and was indeed fired for these transgressions.  The quality of the products speak for themselves.   That said, I agree that the DCS USA employee took an indefensible approach. 

I agree with Golden Sound's review of the Bartok. I listened to it in my system. In my system the Bartok is dark, lacks detail, and sounds closed-in.