Why isn’t more detail always better?

@asvjerry also to help clarify.

The Ohms are still the speakers that I want to listen to the most for pure musical enjoyment. Nothing new there…..it’s for all the same reasons as always. Ohms put the performers in your room best. If I must choose I prefer having the orchestra squeezed into my room like a mini concert venue.

Nearfield listening is for immersing yourself in the recording. It’s more about the recording itself and less about pure musical enjoyment.

Two totally different listening experiences. Both enjoyable in different ways.

Both benefit from more detail, dynamics, etc. All those good things that make music interesting. I’m getting more of that now than ever with some recent enhancements upstream.

It’s an interesting thing that I think you have to experience in order to appreciate.

I am fortunate that I get to enjoy the best of both worlds. YMMV

cheers!

@ghdprentice @lalitk @whart and others — great points & discussion!

I must say, this thread has proven people can discuss a subject at length without someone pissing in someone else’s post toasties. Kudos to all.

My two cents:

Low (volume) level detail can get lost in noise, so chasing hum and AC noise can pay detail dividends. This detail can include pretty much the whole spectrum of frequencies.

Most of us (myself included) tend to think of detail or lack of as occurring in the higher frequencies in the realm covered by tweeters.  Some mechanical aspects of tweeters impact detail like low mass (speed) and low distortion, but assuming quality tweeters, much of what we perceive as detail is driven by the amplitude (volume) from the tweeter. 

In my experience contributing to speaker design a LOOOONG time ago, we could increase the volume of the tweeter and it would enhance the level of detail we perceived.  Cymbals would shimmer, the attack at the beginning of a guitar note was addictively clean.  Life was good.  Things I had never heard were uncovered, like noticing the piano player was quietly singing along or tapping his toes to the beat.  Percussion at the back of the hall on classical recordings was “right there” instead of smeared across the back of the soundstage.

However…  we eventually noticed the downside to all this detail; fatigue.  Whereas before our listening sessions often lasted long into the night, now we had had enough after an hour or two.  On some recordings, in particular digital recordings, it felt like I needed to duck when a cymbal TING flew past my face.  All this detail was masking the glorious midrange we had worked so hard to achieve.  

Midrange is the meat and potatoes for those of us who love to get sucked into the involvement of great recordings where we look up and hours have passed in heady enjoyment. 

Mercifully, I’ve come to my point. All speaker manufacturers deal with this balancing act. Hotter tweeters produce more addictive detail, but at the risk of causing less musical and more fatiguing results. 

We as audiophiles can impact the balancing decisions made by our speakers designers with the equipment we choose, interconnects, room treatment, speaker placement, etc, but that’s a whole different set of subjects. 
 

@waytoomuchstuff ...as one who accompanied spouse to her 50th HS reunion over Halloween wknd.....both agreed an excuse to visit NYC over the following wk.

DJ lame....crowd overdressed....if not in the company of one of her 2 friends then & now, unrecognized....self a stranger on a stranger chunk of the planet....

...and hadn't even been to Manhattan yet....*LOL*

Missed return from Newark by minutes.... "WTF is plan B.S?!"

Renter (NEW! 300 on a Nissan sedan for 40$/d, no limit mi.....)

Watch this, commuters....700 mi. in 11ish hrs., 80~85 as poss. on Interstates.

Spouse has learned how to 'push it' from yours unruly....❤....;)   )

End of day, worth it to escape the flood routines, thanx Helene...

@mapman , GF, zed argument from your DIY Walsh adherent here...👍😉

Re-arranging here into a 'proper' Walsh surround w/sub to prove to spouse that a pair of Maggies will suck.  Even if I tag the ESS amts' along to tag along...which require nil space....

Have 4, can astound soon; surround amt's of the same caricature's....just like IRL....*wooosh *L*

@dishman442  Yeah, it's only when the raw meat gets tossed in that things get 'complicated'... ;)

+10, Yes, only gets more involved when we bring our stuff home that the formulas get involved, drastically by the space we try to make it 'happen' within.

DSP can improve, but likely never cure the 'random locale' we attempt to live and live with re audio endeavors...

SAV can be a sofa too high to surmount....unless you are or have the wallet to become a monk..... ;)

@asvjerry Tissue on the Yammy NS10s.