WHY DO SOME AUDIOPHILES TRY TO TELL OTHERS WHAT THEY CAN OR CAN’T HEAR IN A SYSTEM?


I ask the question. Because I have had several discussions on Audiogon where certain posters will try to tell another person what they can or can’t hear in a system. Most of the time never hearing or having experiences either the piece of equipment, cables etc. It is usually against those that spend money on more expensive equipment and cabling. Why is this so prevalent.  

calvinj

Perspective is everything.

To some (maybe most?) here my vintage audio system would probably be considered "mediocre" at best; especially to those who wouldn't think twice about purchasing $5K cables, $10K speakers, etc. I'm sure if I offered it up for discussion and asked for critique I would receive plenty.

Yet, to the average "layperson" who maybe recalls memories of a Dad or uncle who had a higher end system back in the 1960s / 1970s... my system might be looked at as phenomenally good.

Very different perspectives regarding the exact same pieces of equipment and setup.

I will say that I have found satisfaction with where I am now - and I think that is an undervalued position to be in. I do, however, totally understand that for some in this hobby, it's the excitement of the chase, so to speak; the endless quest for improvement - whether through actual scientifically measurable progress or just in the "this sounds better to me"... I don't feel the need to debate either methodology. If that's what floats your boat, it's all good.

+1 @cleeds 

Unfortunately turning on most media outlets now produces a large of “experts” all interested in telling you what you should believe and how you should behave.

Or get “our app” and we will tell what you should buy for the rest of the life of your phone!

There is nothing like a guy who has never even listened to smthg tell me what I’m not hearing because I can not trust my brain not to lie to me. GTFOH! 

OP asks what is perhaps the most profound question ever asked here.  It is one which touches upon age-old human behavior far beyond the narrow confines of high-end audio.