Perhaps the most annoying myth in audio of 2025? Talking about Loudness!


It is said far too often that the louder speaker will sound better, even by 1 decibel. I’ve found this statement to be supremely inaccurate. Anyone feels the same way or differently?

I feel the opposite to be true, once the speaker has reached a comfortable level, somewhere around 65-72 decibel, getting louder than that ought to sound worse for me. It usually sounds worse for a number of reason, room acoustic interactions, speaker cabinets, small distortion of drivers, etc.

 

Many years in this hobby has taught me to listen to things like smoothness, clarity, separation, microdynamics. An absolutely huge trait right now for me is how effortless is the sound. If it sounds strained, it’s not good to my ears, and many speakers sound strained to a degree even at average 70 db. After owning electrostats, I find many box speakers to lack the purity that I aim for. It gets worse the louder the box speakers get. 

128x128samureyex

Many factors come into play when comparing hifis at various loudness levels, including personal preference. So its really kind of a moot point.

At AVS and elsewhere, they love to say the louder speaker will sound better. If a comparison wasn't db matched, it immediately becomes invalid. Saw somewhere yesterday that someone quoted a famous person name Toole in which Toole said the louder speakers will sound better, even by 1 decibel.

I find it to be ridiculous.

In the correct room, louder sounds incredible. It does in mine. However my 70 yr old ears wouldn't take well to anything over 75 db for long sessions. But this way I should have many more years of high quality listening. 70 db is what I shoot for and it still sounds great, just not the being in the concert room type of experience. But I always wear audiophile earplugs for all concerts anyway. Loud music listening is something enjoyed until it results in tinnitus, or worse, loss of hearing. 

WHen a/b testing, you do want same loudness for both.  

That's different than saying louder is always better. The answer to that one is the usual "it depends".

I went to a concert at Boston Symphony Hall last weekend, sitting in row Z, middle of the hall.  Crescendos hit 90dB in the first and fourth movements of Mahler Symphony #4.  At home, I play it quite a bit softer. But to feel the envelopment one hears in the hall, it has to be louder than my wife would like!  She won’t go to Mahler concerts usually.