Last Critical Tweak… how to quell occasional high harshness…?


Dear Audiogon Community,

 

I am so impressed with the insight and obsession we all share with this musical alchemy of electrons. I write to address a simple problem through as simple (and hopefully relatively inexpensively) as possible… though before such elegant maneuvers, an overly verbose and fussy description:

 

 

Harshness in the highs…. Trumpets and some vocals now make my ears shrill at times. My aging ears! It is so close to musical bliss, but this slight edgyness must be quelled!

 

This song, horns seem to shatter. 

This song, vocals seem to pierce. 

 

I recently leveled an entirely new system. My last tweak was to move my main gain tube to Mullards, and the Brimar NOS tubes to the outer gain location. The mullards afforded a richness and expansiveness, a forward mid and elegance, but introduced the occasional shrillness which I seek to quell. 

 

My musical electron dance is as follows on the streaming side:

 

Nagra Streamer —> Audio Zen MC2 Coax —> Halo Audio Spring 2 Level 3 Kitsune —> Duelund 16 GA Interconnect —> Prima Luna Dialogue Premium HP —> Brimar NOS outer tube and Mullard NOS main gain tube —> Gold Lion KT77 Power tubes —> Duelund 16GA Speaker wire —> Pure Audio Project Duet Horn’s with a gold silver oil Mundorf Cap upgrade —> Duelund wire to the horn and the 15” Woofer. 

 

Fun yes! Devine! But how to quell this one last occasional shrillness?

 

Thoughts:

-Speaker Wire to 12 GA

-DAC - Amp Interconnect changed to something that mellows out the shrill

-Main Gain tube upgraded from a Mullard NOS to something else… (I believe there was a slightly higher grade Mullard?)

-Nagra Stream - DAC Coax cable upgraded to something mellower….?

 

Open to any and all suggestions! Thank you so much for your insights. 

 

R. 

whyrichard

I was typing very fast earlier.  I stand by my statement but wanted to expand a little.  I've found that harshness in the mid-treble, especially when it sounds more like distortion is often room dependent and does not easily yield to DSP or EQ without also suppressing the treble overall. 

It sounds at first like an equipment problem, you don't hear it until you turn up the volume.  You turn down the treble, distortion is gone but so is the treble! 

It has to do with our ear brain mechanism and time.  Besiddes sitting very close to the speakers you can try using temporary things like blankets or pillows in strategic places to see if that helps.  One area which is usually not treated where  I find hash can live is the floor/wall behind and between the speakers.  Fortunately it's super easy to throw a pillow or two there to test. 

Another solution is to add a Stack Audio Smoothlan @ less than $300 [unless tariffs prevail].  It worked out very well for me.  Room treatment also.

Mundorf caps slipped by me, yes, these could be issue. These can spotlight or accentuate higher freq. is some setups. Jupiter copper foils, Audyn True copper Max, Duelund CAST amongst others may alleviate issue.

Perhaps the simplest and most effective thing would be to add Duelund 0.01uf bypass cap to those Mundorfs. You could be quite surprised by how such a little tweak can alter voicing in such a profound way. In my case needed a bit more air, spaciousness on top, went with the Duelund silver bypass cap, wonderful add! Read the many reviews on these. As for Duelund general house sound, natural, effortless sound quality are in the substantial majority of reviews, and this my experience with a their caps, resistors, wire over many years. Negative reviews are outliers, some other issue in those setups, one can likely find negative reviews on virtually every audio product ever produced. 

 

The Cardas Clear IC while a very nice cable isn't going to solve this issue, in fact it could exacerbate the issue being a more resolving cable than Duelund.

Hello all,

 

I’ve taken a few moves and have some updates. 

 

My test track for this diagnosis is the lovely and melloncoly: 

Confronting Inertia by John Adler. The horn peaks at: 2:46, 3:50, 4:40, 5:27, 

 

Responses to many of your questions / comments: 

-Power cords are all stock, on a decent power strip designed for audio gear I bought years ago

-Speaker placement has been fine tuned to work well, i don’t think this is an issue

-Room Treatment I have yet to take on, but I hear from many other Open Baffle and Pure Audio Project owners that they actually removed room treatment to better effect with these speakers. Open Baffle seems to use the room to some degree. 

 

SO…. I have been tweaking in an attempt to track down the high frequency shrill I describe, and hear in spades in the above mentioned John Adler piece. I have tried:

 

-Tube swaps. The Mullard’s on the main gain position (both NOS and new) have the shrill. When I put the Brimars in the main gain the shrill disappears to about 10%, but I loose all the joy of the mids from the Mullards… this is not a preferred solution. 

-New RCA: I recently obtained the Silversmith RCA Interconnects. It’s gorgeous and wonderful and musical. The Shrill is reduced slightly, to about 80%. 

-Old RCA: When I swap out my old Encore II RCA, the shrill mostly disappears. The sound  overall is muted and so this route is not preferred in general. 

-Duelund RCA 16GA, on the Frybaby for extra long: High Harshness is very very present!

 

I am thinking the Duelund 16 speaker cables and internal wiring is the source of the remaining high frequency shrill… in my system… 

 

And for that, I am thinking, based on a review of other Pure Audio Project owners, trying  internal wiring of AntiCables (which version?) and then perhaps a speaker wire change from Duelund….

 

Does that sound right? 

 

I would love to upgrade the power throughout but that sounds to be way out of my current budget… (10K for amp, streamer, dac…?) What is the first affordable bang for buck first step to addressing power? 

The crossover modifications (yes I already upgraded the Cap to Mundorf silver/gold oil, as per PAP’s recommendations…) are interesting, and will consider if all else fails. 

Thank you all for your insights and suggestions. 

Onwards to audio bliss! 

 

R.