Which Tonearm to go for VPI HW-19 III?

Based on my own experience with the VPI "HW" series turntables, I suggest you begin by upgrading to the HW-19 Mk 4 version. The heavier platter and new suspension springs make a noticeable improvement in performance, which in turns makes a better platform for a higher quality tonearm. If you get the "Mk 4" upgrade package, you will also need to buy the thicker acrylic "Super" armboard, to compensate for the increased height of the platter. When I upgraded my "Mk 3" to the "Mk 4" version, I was very pleased with the substantial improvement in performance. Shortly after making the upgrade, I bought a Rega RB-900, which proved to be an excellent combination with the "Mk 4" turntable.

A used Rega RB-900 is a fine value, as is the VPI JMW 10.5 (used) or JWM 10.0.

Steve, Sdcampbell hit that one right on the head. The MkIV upgrade is VERY significant. I also use the RB900 arm. If you can afford the MkIV upgrade, do it. Your stock RB300 arm may fall slightly short after the upgrade.

Although, your 300 arm can be upgraded quite nicely. See below:

http://www.tonearm.co.uk/1-rega-mod-modification.htm

OR........

http://www.expressimoaudio.com/cart/shop.html#

The RB900 arm is a very nice arm. But, it is even better with some of the mods such as VTA adjuster, Heavyweight counterweight and internal wiring. All those same mods can be performed to your 300 arm (which you already own). If you ever decide to upgrade to the 900 arm, you could carry over the mod. parts from the 300.

Best of luck, Ed.

I hear that the Eminent Technology arm is a great fit. I have the ET2 arm on another table and believe it is the best turntable to support this arm.
I strongly suggest you investigate this option.

I agree with Scott and Ed, the mk IV upgrade is well worth it. If you want to take it further, you can add the Stand Alone Motor Assembly (SAMA) and Synchronous Drive System (SDS). That takes the HW-19 concept about as far as it can go, which is pretty far indeed. I'm happy using the JMW 10.5 tonearm with my full blown HW-19 setup. I never tried the Rega RB-900, so I cannot compare. I did originally have a RB-300 and I'm much happier with the sound of the 10.5 tonearm.
The mk IV upgrade is the first place to start though.

Regards,
John