Wharfedale Emerald 93 Opinions


I own a pair of Wharfedale Emerald 93 bookshelf speakers mated with a Wharfedale sub. These are the only (entry-level?) high-end speakers I have owned so I have no idea how these compare with other speakers. Are these as good as Paradigm Reference Studio 20s? Axiom M22Tis? How much would one have to spend to get significantly better performance? Any opinions welcome.

If it matters, my other equipment consists of an NAD C370 integrated amp, Sony 222ES CD/SACD player, and a Nady 15 band/channel eq (which can potentially smooth out peaks and valleys in the frequency response if I can identify them). I listen to a wide range of music: rock, jazz, classical, early.

Tony
socprof
A moment of history, off-topic by all but a millmeter: Wharfedale did not always make mass-market speakers, designed to push buyers' buttons in large-surface stores. Lots of 'goners learned theory from Wharfedale chief engineer G.A. Briggs' "Cabinet Handbook", published in the late '50s IIRC. Some of us even built one of Briggs' designs.

Wharfedale drivers, and indeed complete speakers, were at one point among the very best you could buy. The company was sold to the Rank organisation, and its engineers went on to form other companies later, among them Castle. The Wharfedale research legacy is very much alive today... perhaps just a bit less at the present company's premises than elsewhere.
Take the comments from Scottht with a very large grain of salt. For starters, Wharfedale is not a speaker line but a brand, with MANY different lines. Those different lines vary dramatically when it comes to sound quality. As Mwilson mentioned, the Valdus line represents an excellent value for its intended market and can be quite enjoyable, but wouldn't qualify as an "audiophile quality" speaker. But the Emerald line is a far cry above the Valdus in terms of sound quality. It's been a long time since I heard any Emeralds and I have not heard the 93's. I heard the largest of the floorstanders in that line and would have to say that I preferred their sound to that of many models in the Paradigm line at that time. That said, I should also state that I do not particularly care for the "Paradigm sound". At that time, all of their models sounded better suited to home theater than music. I have not heard any speaker from Axiom, so cannot comment.

If you enjoy the "Wharfedale sound" and a speaker upgrade is what you seek, the Pacific line or its successor (the Evo line) may be the place to look, as they are a significant improvement over the Emeralds. I have not heard any Evo, but I own Pacific Pi-40's and Pi-30's and have no complaints. If you haven't the room for floorstanders, consider the Diamond line. I have not heard them, but a friend uses them in his office and claims that the glowing reviews from 'What Hi-fi' are correct. As a brand, Wharfedale isn't the last name in speaker performance, but the value for the $ factor is very high.

As far as the $ question is concerned, that's nearly impossible to answer. Many people have spent far more on speakers that I think do not sound as good. For example, I have a friend with very expensive bookshelf speakers. I could never be happy with the limited range of a bookshelf speaker and will gladly sacrifice a little clarity in the midrange to get a few extra Hz on the low end from a full size speaker. He disagrees, preferring the sweetest mids possible at the sacrifice of low end. Do his mids sound better than mine...yes, but I've got bass he can't produce. He likes his speakers more than he likes mine and I like mine more than his. So who spent what on better speakers? There is just too much subjectivity involved. As Scottht points out, one man's trash is another's treasure. All that really matters is what sounds good to you. I would suggest listening to as many brands and models as possible. A trip to a decent hi-fi shop is time well spent, even if you have to travel to do it. Good luck...
I own two sets of Wharfedales - Diamond 7.2's and the MFM-1's. They are not bad speakers for the money, especially the Diamonds - read a review on them.
http://www.tnt-audio.com/casse/wharf72e.html

Dave
I forgot to mention that Wharfedale is now owned by IAG, which owns Qaud also. I think they are trying to bring back this speaker name.