Agree 100% with tomic601, the extra 2' and 4' make all the difference. A 10 X 10 room is inappropriate for any planar, 12' X 14' about as small as you can go.
Magnepan and room size, room placement
I have always been a fan of Maggies, but never an owner. I am thinking about them again. One of my issues has always been room size, specifically as it relates to the rule/recommendation that the speakers be placed 3 feet from the front wall. I get the scientific argument about dipoles and the rear sound radiation.
first, let me clarify that I am thinking about the 1.7i or the 0.7, not the big ones. Probably the 0.7.
my room is about 10x10. With a listening sofa of about 30 inches deep along the back wall, if I put the speakers 3 feet from the front wall, the speaker to listener distance is less than 5 feet. Even less if the 3 feet is a minimum. My current speakers (Proac monitors on stands) sit about 20 inches from the front wall. This location was arrived at through much trial an error, and really is a sweet spot. Having said that, I am willing and able to spend some time playing around with position of the Maggies to find their sweet spot.
but my question really is, just how important is the 3 foot rule/recommendation? Does much of the sound waves really get cancelled out? Does anyone have experience with Magnepan closer the the wall (18-24 inches) ? What aspect of the sound do you know from experience (or would suspect) would be most compromised by being too close to the front wall?
While the obvious answer is a home demo, talking on the phone to my two local dealers (in Chicago burbs and Madison, Wisconsin) indicate that a home demo is not possible to to their concerns of transportation damage to the large speakers, as I live 1-1/2 hour drive from either.
thanks for your help,
Bill
first, let me clarify that I am thinking about the 1.7i or the 0.7, not the big ones. Probably the 0.7.
my room is about 10x10. With a listening sofa of about 30 inches deep along the back wall, if I put the speakers 3 feet from the front wall, the speaker to listener distance is less than 5 feet. Even less if the 3 feet is a minimum. My current speakers (Proac monitors on stands) sit about 20 inches from the front wall. This location was arrived at through much trial an error, and really is a sweet spot. Having said that, I am willing and able to spend some time playing around with position of the Maggies to find their sweet spot.
but my question really is, just how important is the 3 foot rule/recommendation? Does much of the sound waves really get cancelled out? Does anyone have experience with Magnepan closer the the wall (18-24 inches) ? What aspect of the sound do you know from experience (or would suspect) would be most compromised by being too close to the front wall?
While the obvious answer is a home demo, talking on the phone to my two local dealers (in Chicago burbs and Madison, Wisconsin) indicate that a home demo is not possible to to their concerns of transportation damage to the large speakers, as I live 1-1/2 hour drive from either.
thanks for your help,
Bill
- ...
- 16 posts total
- 16 posts total