o10, I had an interesting reaction to "Speak Low", although I've certainly experienced it before.
This applies to songs with lyrics since that establishes the context. To me, "Speak Low" suggests no more than a moderate level (duh!) and a slow rhythm. Sonny's version was too quick paced, so lost the meaning of the song.
I appreciate this may be a personal thing, so may not a problem for others. But for me that is an important part of the "interpretation" of any song. The tempo sets the mood and the mood should match the song, particularly when there are lyrics to guide us.
Another example, can you imagine any real, heart-felt blues played at a fast tempo?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6SP5JHLqXM8
This applies to songs with lyrics since that establishes the context. To me, "Speak Low" suggests no more than a moderate level (duh!) and a slow rhythm. Sonny's version was too quick paced, so lost the meaning of the song.
I appreciate this may be a personal thing, so may not a problem for others. But for me that is an important part of the "interpretation" of any song. The tempo sets the mood and the mood should match the song, particularly when there are lyrics to guide us.
Another example, can you imagine any real, heart-felt blues played at a fast tempo?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6SP5JHLqXM8