This site is a business first and foremost selling luxury items. People come here to sell and buy things and make money. The value of many of those things is very subjective. Don’t let anyone fool you into believing there are no bad apples and everything in between. There is no panacea. Credibility is earned, not automatically granted. Just call it like it is. You can’t please all the people all the time. But that won’t stop some rabid marketers from claiming to. They are just doing their job.
Advice on....Snake Oil
So, I get it. You purchase something and other claim it's snake oil. Or they purchase snake oil and you lay claim to the adage.
My one question,
What is the general consensus a reputable brand would spend considerable time, resources and finances to create a product that is or what some would call "snake oil".
My belief is that a lot of brands (PS Audio, Isoacoustics, Audioquest) would probably better spend their time developing and creating an impact rather than making a questionable product. Any dialogue to be had or am I off base?
My one question,
What is the general consensus a reputable brand would spend considerable time, resources and finances to create a product that is or what some would call "snake oil".
My belief is that a lot of brands (PS Audio, Isoacoustics, Audioquest) would probably better spend their time developing and creating an impact rather than making a questionable product. Any dialogue to be had or am I off base?
- ...
- 54 posts total
mapman Just call fraud fraud when it occurs.I've always thought it odd that so many here are quick to charge fraud, yet none (to my knowledge) have ever filed a fraud complaint with authorities. So although the accusers often claim their goal is to protect the "gullible" and misinformed, it's obvious that is not their genuine interest. |
It can be very difficult to prove fraud legally. Especially when the fraud has to do with largely subjective judgement such as sound quality. This entire site is basically about sound quality and various claims about it which is mostly a subjective judgement. But it is very naive to assert fraud does not exist especially in that kind of environment. In many cases it gets downgraded to “snake oil”. Credibility is really the only thing one has here in the eyes of others and worth preserving. It is not credible to assert that all here are perfect angels all the time as a result of their common love or obsession with sound. My advice: Just be realistic and steer the course. There are always a few bad apples. Trust but verify when called for. Otherwise just have fun! |
Dill, your first post is spot on, in very few words. They don’t want , or can’t spend, or entrenched in their “science”. exactly cleeds, they’re not trying to protect anything except to keep their personal bubble from bursting. They’re the ones when shown the blue pill and red pill, run away from either. There may very well be people who feel they don’t hear a difference, or feel, what they hear justifies the expense. There’s not a thing wrong with that, they’re not out trying to convince anyone that they didn’t hear what they claim they did. It makes no sense to spend if the value is not there for you. Why they are so hell bent on trying to convince us not to believe our own ears, not to spend for our own enjoyment ( last I checked, it’s my money I’m spending) |
what some would call "snake oil".
Why? Because as we know from CV19, propaganda goes a veryyyy longgg way. You can not always believe what you read, hear, As Kevin Deal says at Upscale aAudio,, <<If they are not showing pics of the guts of any component = means they are hiding something>> He is right. Its the old saying, a pic tells a thosand words,, before i make any purcahse i carefully look at the guts, and weight. If it looks gorgeous from the outside, but inside pic looks like garbage,, and weight is puny,, I know its all hype. Guts + weight says alot. Who wants to pay top $ for a toy sized transformer? Lets rephrase your **snakeoil** which really only applies to mods/upgrades (new caps, new resistors new tubes) , for describing a components reputation, lets tag it <<hype>> There is alot of hype in this hobby. Snakeoil buster here. |
- 54 posts total