Used McIntosh Amp or better new options out there? - Amplifier or Integrated


A little about me, I am in the process of building my next step up 2-channel system for a listening room that is 17’x13’x12’. Current gear: LS50 and Paradigm Studio 20 v5 + Rotel RA-12 + SB2000 
For me new speakers I’m thinking in the $3-4k price range floor standing speakers. Some of the speakers I’m considering: Dynaudio Evoke 50, KEF R7, Focal Aria 936, Salk Song3 tower and my stretch budget option is the 805 D3s. 
I mostly listen to Jazz, orchestra/instrumental, Pop, some trance/electronic and Classic rock. I’m a fan of a clean but less harsh highs, non shouty mids and tight controlled bass. 

Now back to the topic at hand. I came across a used MC152 at a local high end audio store. The sales guy indicated this was originally a demo amp from their store that one of their regulars bought and recently traded it in for a large Mac amp. He indicated its from 2017, but no way for me to know for sure (not sure if the serial number will let me look it up?). I auditioned this amp on speakers they had in store and I really liked the sound it produced on my usual music tracks. However the left VU meter needle on this amp was not working. Apart from that looked in mint condition, not scratches, no marks on the screws that would indicate tampering. The dealer said he’ll get it serviced from a local third party McIntosh repair shop and can then sell it to me once fixed and I’m satisfied with its condition. They are asking $2.8k for this amp, which is what attracted me to it given how expensive they are normally. 

Now my question is, should I bother taking the plunge? Now that I found out the VU meter is broken, I’m a little turned off since someone is now going to open this thing up (probably for the first time). I’ve heard Macs are bullet proof and last for ever, but does anyone see any red flags here or anything I should look for?

Given the $3k ish price range, is there something else I could consider in this range (I prefer Class AB or Tube or Tube Hybrid). Is paying close to retail for a new MC152 from a dealer worth the extra money (warranty and less anxiety)?  This is the first time I’m buying in this price range, so I want to make sure. I’m open to both a good stereo power amp or an integrated as long as its a sizeable upgrade from my RA-12. If its only an amp, I intend to us the RA-12 as a preamp for now till I can budget for a good tube preamp (Rogue Audio perhaps) 

I ideally wanted to stay at about $6k for speaker + amp and was leaning towards one of the Dynaudio towers + a parasound Halo or Rotel RA-1592 / 1582 MkII type amp. I always dreamed of owning a McIntosh or Luxman but couldn’t stomach to full retail price on those beauties. Any help to reduce my anxiety or providing some suggestions would be much appreciated :) 

Thank you! 
sr20022002
Well, the MAC's are certainly good stuff and the resale on them hold well through the decades.   There are other good tube amps out there, too, you might consider.   I had a MAC 275 in my system for while, which was a loaner, so after a while I had to begrudgingly give it back.   I did love the sound, to be sure.  All those tubes glowing red at night was pure sex appeal.  (At least my audiophile friends thought so.)

I wouldn't worry about opening the unit up for repair.  If the repair shop is certified MAC, you will have no problems.  Heck, if it is a highly regarded tube repair shop, you won't have a problem.
 
I think the real question you need to ask yourself is "how" you listen.   With good solid state, you can leave it on all day, while you are home or not, listening critically or not, even leave it on all night, it won't care, it will just keep playing.    With tubes, well, they do care.   They have a short lifespan compared to solid state.   At some point, they will wear out, and you will spend a hundred or two to replace them.   So, I just don't let the tubes run unless I am critically listening, or at least, in the same room with them.    The rest of the time I use the solid state home theater to fill the house with sound and bring life to movies.   

The last question you need to ask yourself, although it appears you already asked and answered, is whether you want to go down the tube path.   Once you do, and you like what you find, you will then want a tube preamp, a tube CD player, a tube crossover (if you use one), heck you will probably want tubes in your cereal bowl in the mornings. :-)  The tube gear will act like a giant backhoe working overtime in your wallet.   If you don't like what you find, well, in that case tube gear holds resale well, if you bought good stuff to begin with.   

As for buying used, well, it is just a smaller bucket on the backhoe....
@sr20022002
"as long as its a sizeable upgrade from my RA-12"..."I’m a fan of a clean but less harsh highs, non shouty mids and tight controlled bass."... "Any help to reduce my anxiety or providing some suggestions would be much appreciated :)"


Do you need to buy/upgrade amps and speakers together all at once? Can you try a partial upgrade to start, to apply more $ to amp or speakers first.

+1 what spatialking said. "How" you listen is key for a SS vs. Tube decision. Also, might need to decide if you are stuck on McIntosh. Separates can be costly.

You could ask them to demo the MC152 before they fix the meters. Good dealers do demos. Try it with your LS50s and SB2000 before you buy. It will give you ideas, enough to decide to explore tubes or not.
You’ve always wanted a Macintosh. It’s a little over half price of a new one. Ask the dealer to throw in a set of new power tubes and a 12 month warranty and take it.