MM Phono preamp under $200 Recommendations

Find a used Pass Lab Pearl. You may have to post WTB on different audio web sights, DIY forum for one. You can find them in you price range. I think they play in the $1000 range for dirt cheap used. Add some better signal caps and can compete with even higher priced amps.

I would probably get some used Lehmann.

I got a NAD I will sell yah

What cartridge are you using? Might want to consider how much load and gain flexibility you may require. 

Schiit Mani, or Cambridge DUO - DOU is currently the leader over at ASR for best measurements (Although they have not done a ton of Phono stages at this point)