@jasonbourne52 - "Far from scientific!"
I think if you read my post, you will find no claims of scientific validity. I know of no suitable tests of this propositiion that are double blind and adequately account for Type I and Type II statistical error. In fact, I don’t know of any peer-reviewed, published experiments that explore differences among transports.
I would add that without people's reporting their experiences, science (if it were funded) would not know what to investigate. The ideal, after all, is to produce sound that is subjectively convincing.
If audio were entirely a scientific endeavor, no one would play LPs, and we’d understand why SACDs sound better to many, despite being hugely overspecified and having a large HF noise envelope. But they do and they do and as Nelson Pass said: "It’s entertainment, not brain surgery."