NAS/Streamer or server/player?


Recently my server/player died due to a major power issue to my house. So now I am considering whether to use another music server/player or spend the same $ (say ~USD$8-10k) on a player/streamer only and link to a dedicated Synology NAS that I have spare (but with a low end processor and HDDs).

I use a Chord Dave as pre amp/DAC direct to a Vitus RS-101. I use Roon.

What thoughts do you guys have on the what option and equipment will give the best SQ outcome and why?

Thanks in advance for the help.

kamphu

Synology mirror raid 4TB, ditto a Netgear…what a royal PITA…. USB SSD or stick gonna rule the world…

This is why I'm obsessive about surge protection.  Protection in the service panel as required by NEC 2020, and protection on all of my sensitive equipment.  My PC's, stereo, even my network gear is ridiculously protected.  It's not just the cost, it's the effort of replacement.  I even use a fiber optic network cable to air-gap the cable modem from my internal Ethernet and Wifi. 

I recommend looking at Aurender. I have pursued high end digital sound since the advent of the CD. After owning an Auralic Aries G2 streamer, and a number of lessor solutions I got a Aurender N100, the sound quality is simply amazing so after auditioning their amazing N10 model $8K (and lots of research)… I can recommend it without qualification. I chose their flagship the W20SE (~$22K). This is all these guys do and have it down to an art. You will find many of them all over audio shows, they are the standard for companies to use unless they make their own. Surprisingly Linn also makes world class streamers..

Typically they come with some internal solid state storage, with options for more. I have NAS… which is accessible… but I just copied it into my Aurrender in case the network is down… I have used it once over the last year as there is no sonic advantage of internally stored files or CDs… so I just use Qobuz.

Aurenders are built without compromise to maximize sound quality. Streamed music in my system now is at the same quality level as my great analog rig (see my systems under my ID). Completely changed what and how I listened to music, since I now have access to nearly infinite music for the price of a CD per month. Their Conductor app for controlling and managing music is great. I have 28tb of storage at home.. no longer use it for music.

I recommend Melco.  It's a great NAS and can also be a server.  It sounded much better than the Synolgy NAS that it replaced

Get a synology NAS and a Sonore or Lumin U1.  Keep it simple.  Both will be a great roon streamer and the NAS should be RAID.  Way under your budget you listed.