I don't want to beat a dead horse but I'm bugged.

Maybe the problem is not a math problem and that is the difficulty.

Great post! thanks...

Especially that part:

Every time you make a decision on even/odd, you are throwing away information. That knowledge does not carry to the next step, therefore you can never go backwards, only forwards.

You are right....Then we need a new theory of information which basis are explained in the Indian scientist book...And a new way to do non Turing mathematic....

Hearing is not explained by being the solution of a mathematical problem in the usual sense of the word..,

It is not even the result of a decision based algorithm, there is no linear Turing computing here in the brain/ear, but more an integrated chain of non excluding choices converging without rejecting anything, but more integrating everything , like a "resonating" tree of which we consciously perceive only some leafs... Sound/silence is already meaning not mere sound...

All the book of Anirban Bandyopadhyay is a reflection about that and an explanation i cannot resume save with a few metaphors...

I cannot resume that here...

Read this page:

https://nanobraintech.com/about/

My goal are not to explain sound or hearing, only to point to something which cannot be understood with the objective/subjective external usual border ... Meaning is neither objective nor subjective and sound is already meaning...

Music is the meaning of this meaning....

By the way it is comical but also tragic to see grown men acting like children in a schoolyard, and instead of giving arguments, giving a gift approval point to someone they approve because he just insult or denigrate someone else instead of answering or discussing ...Inmates act like that too...Sheeps, children or mature, are sheeps...They feel better in a group where thinking is replaced by gestures...Before we were men, long time ago, we were apes without thinking smiles nor language...

Many people speak exactly like that all around the world right now, the gestures are only a propaganda sign conditioned system, they all obey it...

The conditioning by facebook tweeter, etc, instead of stimulating thinking, put people in the gestures labelling zoo....

It is life... 😁😊

 

By the way it is comical but also tragic to see grown men acting like children in a schoolyard, and instead of giving arguments, giving a gift approval point to someone they approve because he just insult or denigrate someone else instead of answering or discussing ...Inmates act like that too...Sheeps, children or mature, are sheeps...They feel better in a group where thinking is replaced by gestures...Before we were men, long time ago, we were apes without thinking smiles nor language...

Many people speak exactly like that all around the world right now, the gestures are only a propaganda sign conditioned system, they all obey it...

The conditioning by facebook tweeter, etc, instead of stimulating thinking, put people in the gestures labelling zoo....

 

It is life... 😁😊

But we could agree on what makes a denigrating post and then track whether posts are becoming more or less civil over time.

So much like the topic of the thread, that could be measured.

Right now we have feelings and magic.

• Feelings and emotions for the music.
• Feelings and emotion for the arguments and posts.
• And the magic of earth and cosmic vibrations.
• Versus trhe magic of strings and wood wind vibrations.

Might as well keep it going.

Does it mean that your ears are better than anything else on this earth

I don't think so.

Does it mean you have golden ears

Probably not but I might be a better listener than average.

Does it mean your experiences are greater than anyone elses

I Probably have more experience than average, less than some in the industry.  

Does it mean that your are the only one that needs to like what you hear

Well, I try to please me, I don't care about what others might like.

Does it mean that your hearing is better than any messurment device

My interpretation of what I hear might be better than a raw measurement, yes. 

Have you done the experiment that you go to ASR and look up the WORST measuring power amplifier that Amir has measured.

I'm pretty sure that is why I started this thread. 

@russ69 Your problem was reading a review by Amir.