Are advances in technology making speakers better?

 

I’ve been into high performance audio playback for almost 4 decades and I can’t say I’ve noticed any jaw dropping sound quality difference.

For whatever reason I felt that there seemed to be an actual dip in loudspeaker performance during the 1990s and the early 2000s.

Some folks still hold the original Quad ESL and the BBC LS3/5 in the highest regard. If there was any jaw dropping improvements in sound quality I’m sure they’d be very interested.

I’ve yet to hear the highly regarded Revel Salon 2s which always seem to be up there with the very best when it comes to comparisons.

It’s interesting to note that they are now a 14 year old design.

+1

The OP mentioned…

 

B&w every few years upgrades there speaker line and other manufacturers do this to. But because I have the earlier version does this mean it’s inferior? Cable manufactures do the same thing.

Well did any new technology go into those speakers?
Or what changes were made?

How much more effort is required too perfect a speaker? my speaker is several years old and all the gear and the speaker are all broken in. And now I’m being told to upgrade.

I guess it would be components and integration.
It may be easier to make a decent speaker now using mediocre components like drivers are crossovers.
But to make a more perfect speaker one would assumed that they need more perfect drivers… and also have them integrated.

I can count the drivers on one or two hands that are obviously a step up in some fashion.

The active speakers are a bit easier to make good at a cheaper price point.

I am so confused what should I do?

Personally I would not do a damned thing. Just play them until you find something that is obviously wrong with them, or something is obviously better in new speakers than in your the existing ones.

Maybe buy a new CD or LP every month or two...

Ghdprentice,

I think technological advance makes it easier to achieve any kind of sound from speakers, I just think that the kind of sound the builder is aiming for is a much more important factor than the technology employed to get there.  The Sonus Faber Amati speakers you have in your main system primarily sound the way they sound because the designer voiced them that way.  They don’t employ any radically new technology to get that sound.

@grislybutter Excite - meaning appealing to a potential new market.

Evoke - going back to the loyal base for the classic Dynaudio sound the loyalists have always loved. "Evoke-ing" the great memories of past Dynaudio lines...

@curtdr thanks for sharing. Ya newer and more "exciting" and different does not always translate into long term happiness. Everything new always fades...I'll repeat another old saying..."If it ain't broke..." right?!

@larryi

Maybe we are disagree on the word technology. I consider material science and changes in design (dimensions and configurations technology). Not just say changing from a cone based to a “cube” based for instance. Yes, cones with magnets, ribbon, electrostatic… there and not completely new concepts.

The Amati use “paper” cones… but they are in no way the paper cones of the 1950’s, just like the magnets. Sure they choose voicing, but the speed and resolution is technology dependent.

I don't think we disagree.  The technology is important.  I just think the particular sound the designer is shooting for is much more important to the sound.  One can get very close to any particular sound chosen with technology from the past.  With the hyper-detailed sound of some speakers, the past, might mean only a decade or two back, with the kind of sound of the Amati, slightly older technology will do.  As to speed and resolution, there are plenty of older drivers that can achieve this while still sounding warm and relaxed like your Sonus Faber Amati drivers, but the ones I can think of are pretty expensive and much more impractical and certainly cannot be packaged as beautifully as your speaker (e.g.,Jensen field coil M-10 drivers).

That is not to say that the design of such speakers is easy--it takes a lot of knowledge, experience and experimentation to achieve the kind of sound that Sonus Faber achieves.  That design, and correctly employing whatever technology is available, is the main reason these speakers deliver the kind of sound that you and I like.