Lots of thoughts. I don’t think your equipment including the DAC is terribly warm. That said, it is not like you have obnoxiously bright stuff either.
Thinness can come from a few places. Tell us more about the room. Carpeting? Wall treatment? Pictures, windows, curtains, etc…. How far do you sit from the speakers?
Do you have a subwoofer? Those start rolling off above 50hz and it is going to sound thin at lower volumes. A good sub could help that out potentially. That along could be your issue with fullness. Regarding edginess, That could be a single component. Might be the JC2, might be the pass. I have a Modwright UDP 205 here paired with AGD amp and preamp and it is sweet and musical.
I would try a sub. Let’s here more about your room but you might borrow an amp or preamp from your retailer that you work with to see if it helps.