I’m confused. Please explain.

My system makes Billy Joel sound like Sir Georg Solti.

The goal is to make music sound as close as possible to what is recorded on the medium.   Classical is often used as an example because it is easier to know what a piano sounds like than a rock guitar, as the latter is very dependent on the artist.

When my system was on display at THE Show last month, I got a lot of complements in the form of "the piano really sounds like a piano" or similar.

onhwy61

Unless you were in the mastering room where the sonics are finalized, you have no real idea what a specific recording is supposed to sound like.

That's why every so often I like to make my own live recordings. Although that removes a lot of variables, some remain. The mics, mic preamps, cabling ... it all makes a difference. But it does provide a reference point.

I've been in the midst of live music for 60 years. Trying to replicate that at home is a fool's errand.

+1 @secretguy

to me, it’s just about a reproduction of the music that is enjoyable, relaxing and makes me forget about the cares of the day because I’m into the music.

why should it be more complicated than that?

And that's our hobby in a nutshell: I want a particular sound but I don't really know what that sound is.

That's why I settled for the sound I now have as good enough for me. If circumstances and finances change, then so will my system. Many failed attempts preceded my present stance and now it's very enjoyable. Those who have heard it love the sound. 

Through planning, luck and plain old serendipity, I'm now at the point of diminishing returns. Until then, I'm done fretting over it.

All the best,
Nonoise