Is It Worh Modding An Amp


I have a Primaluna Dialogue One that sits idle as a backup.  I’m debating the idea of having it modded. Problem is I have no idea what can or should be upgraded or if the amp is worth the investment. Id be willing to fork over 500-1000 if it was worth it and made sense compared to what else I could do with the funds.  Curious what people’s experiences and thoughts are? 

brylandgoodman

No.....

Try to understand what you are wanting from you sound.......please don;t tell me more base....

A good beginning.

I'll also say No.

I’ve sent two pieces of gear out to be modded and wasn’t especially pleased each time.

The first was an Adcom GFA-555. It was away so long, I honestly couldn’t tell if there was any improvement. But I was out the money.

The second was a TacT 2.2X. The modifier fell on hard times and never finished my job. Indeed, I never even got the unit back -- a decade ago, it was in pieces somewhere in a storage unit. That was a total loss. Not the usual outcome, but it can happen.

In any case, modding is a poor financial move. Modified gear costs the owner more but is more difficult to sell (and usually sells for less) than unmodified gear.

 

Most tube upgrading services involve swapping out parts, primarily capacitors, for more expensive ones.  This is not necessarily an improvement if the original designer voiced the component and used appropriate parts for the sound the designer was trying to achieve.  I've heard several such "upgrades" that sounded clearly inferior (at least in my opinion based on my taste and the system the amp was tried). 

To do this sort of thing correctly, one must find a technician who knows about the sound of different parts and you must convey what you want from the upgrade (e.g., warmer/lusher sound or greater clarity, etc.).  There is no such thing as an always superior part.

Your best bet might be something non-invasive such as the tube rolling suggested above.  Manufacturers put it the cheapest and most plentiful tubes that will fit their needs.  They need tubes that can be easily replaced so that they can either supply the customer with replacements or make it easy and economical for the customer to replace.  That is not just a matter of saving money.  It does not make sense for a manufacturer to invest in expensive tubes of a particular type when that tube might not fit the customers' taste or match the customers' system.  It makes more sense for the customer to do this.  

Even though I'm a tinkerer by nature, unless there are some known issues with the amp and some known mods to fix the issue, I would not modify the circuit.  Tube rolling is a far safer bet.

On the other hand, has anyone done any cap upgrades to these amps?  I don't see that as a circuit mod, just a parts swap....and it's reversible.