Analogue Productions SACDs


Hi.  I have a question about the Doors SACDs from Analogue Productions/Acoustic Sounds. They are listed as hybrid SACDs, with a CD stereo layer and an SACD 5.1 surround layer.  Would the SACD layer play in stereo if I only have a stereo system?  I asked one of their salesman yesterday, and he didn't know!

kb54

I use a gameDR zero clearance technology 10 - brush cyclone cleaner to  occasionally  clean the lens on my player. It's works on Blue Ray and HD DVD players.

I honestly wouldn't waste my money on SACDs unless you have a top quality player or a good transport and DAC.  A regular CD in a good player or transport/DAC will sound better than a SACD in an Oppo or entry level player that has SACD capability.  There may be some benefit if they have been remastered and improved.

@big_greg 

I could not disagree more, if the SACD was originally recorded in multi-channel high resolution and not badly re-mastered.  Most classical SACDs have superb sound.

By the way, hybrid SACDs have two not three recorded layers, one for the CD layer and one with much higher information density for everything else.  There is enough room for both 2-channel and 5.0 or 5.1 channel DSD versions.

I could almost immediately tell there was something wrong with DSD playback through my then-new Reavon player's internal DACs.  It turned out it was down-sampling DSD to CD-quality PCM.  It is fine when used as a transport with external DACs which decode DSD natively.

Note that by DAC I mean a chipset, not a box containing DACs!

I could not disagree more, if the SACD was originally recorded in multi-channel high resolution and not badly re-mastered. Most classical SACDs have superb sound.

I’m not sure what you're disagreeing with but if you like surround sound, cool. We like what we like. I think it sounds very unnatural and prefer stereo if there is a surround version. 

In my Oppo, it’s in the set up menu. You choose your layer priority. I had to switch it to stereo priority from multi-channel.. Also, had to switch it to DSD. It was converting to PCM.