Audiogon "RECORDINGS TO DIE FOR" list


I've been listening to some of my favorite recordings this weekend and was wondering what others on Audiogon felt were there favorites. We have all seen the Stereophile "Records to Die For", The Absolute Sounds recommended list, Music Directs' list, The Golden Ear, etc. now I'm hoping to assemble the Audiogon "Recordings To Die For". Please list your five favorite recordings, the ones you listen to over and over or play for friends. I would assume the sonic quality is excellent in that this is an audiophile site. The performance and enjoy ability should also be excellent. Please leave your top five, even if they are already chosen so we can discover the very top for the Audiogon listeners. ALSO PLEASE REFRAIN FROM CRITICIZING OTHERS OPINIONS AND JUST LEAVE YOUR FAVORITES!

August 2002: I have compiled a summary and a full printer-friendly list of all of the recommendations below.
click here to view summary
128x128jadem6
The top 5 that I could listen to for ETERNITY... Hmmmm..
Ok, without trying to evenly distribute to the differing styles, based purely on ecstatic listening pleasure:

1. Bach St. Matthew Passion, Concertgebouw Orch conducted by Willem Mengelberg "live" Palm sunday recording. He was not only one of the genius conductors of the century, but the best choirmaster I have ever heard. Listen to the violin and flute solos also. To die for. Absolute transcendental Bach and REAL.

2. Brahms Horn Trio, Joseph Szigeti violin, Horszowski pno, John Barrows horn. They take this way beyond the stratospheres. In my opinion, this kills the famous Busch, Serkin, Brain recording. Good luck finding a copy of this though. The Brahms Piano Trio in C Major with Szigeti, Hess and Casals comes close to this.

3. Mozart Divertimento in E-flat for vln, vla, and cello. Live performance from Prades festival. performed by Joseph Fuchs, Lillian Fuchs, Paul Tortelier. This will not only want to make you die, but also jump off a tall building with a running start. One of the most startling, inspired, live chamber music performances I have ever heard. And such fine playing by all. On Koch International, along with the finest Mozart symphonia concertante on record, which happens to be live by Joe and Lillian Fuchs.

4. Late Beethoven Sonatas, EMI, Artur Schnabel. Schnabel's late beethoven, completely lucid interpretations. Great sound too.

5. the Cavatina from Beethoven's Opus 131, Berlin Phil, conducted by Wilhelm Furtwangler. They actually play it better than any string quartet recording I know of. This performance is a piece of heaven.

As I am a performing musician, I listen to alot of recordings which have some surface noise. I would never trade a mediocre perfectly recorded performance for a noisy artistic one. So be aware of that when you listen to these recordings.
Rickie Lee Jones - "Rickie Lee Jones" self titled LP
Fleetwood Mac - "Fleetwood Mac" self titled LP
Brand X - "Livestock" LP
Kinks - "Schoolboys in Disgrace" LP
Blue Oyster Cult - "Secret Treaties" LP
Can't have just one list! Must have a popular list and a classical one.

POPULAR:
Bob Dylan - "Love and Theft"
Bob Dylan - "Blood on the Tracks"
Emmylou Harris - "Pieces of the Sky"
Allman Brothers - "Eat a Peach"
Van Morrison - "Astral Weeks"

CLASSICAL:
JS Bach - "Cello Suites" (Fournier, Archiv)
Grieg - "Lyric Pieces" (Pletnev, piano; DG)
Mozart - "Complete Piano Sonatas" (Uchida, Philips)
Mussorgsky - "Pictures from an Exhibition" (Pletnev, piano, Virgin)
Rachmaninov - "Piano Concerto No. 3 (Marta Argerich)
Not in order, all on vinyl:
Eric Clapton & BB King, Riding With the King
Issac Stern & Zubin Metha, Brahms Violin Conc.
Glen Gould, Goldberg Variations, Bach
Stevie Ray Vaughn, Couldn't Stand the Weather
Mike Bloomfield & Al Kooper, Super Session
Eric Clapton: "Unplugged". I get a sense of the sound bouncing off of the auditorium walls, with spaciousness, and he sounds very warm. Guitar strings are crisp, and leave the speaker, coming out boldly into the room. Very warm, and very 3 dimensional. Also very upbeat, and musical. His vocal presence is very good, yet with excellent separation. Images are very well defined, with good texture, yet not too strong. Very good placement. I really like the piano also. The pacing is adds to the overall musicality, and I have found this to be 1 of 2 of my favorite cd's.