I think you made a good decision as described based on my limited exposure to the Mofis in general. Enjoy!
MoFi Sourcepoint 888 Speakers
I recently found myself with a little extra money, and after some thought and having read so many positive things, I decided to try a pair of the Sourcepoint 888's. I had actually been set on a pair of JBL HDI 3800's, but I couldn't find a set in my price range as they were closing out remaining stock, and they were all the more expensive black lacquer.
Anyway, the MoFi's seemed to fit the bill. I was looking for a gutsier mid-bass, the one failing of my current speakers (Odyssey Kismet Reference), which are actually wonderful otherwise. Still, mid-bass is responsible for some of the oomph and forward momentum in music, especially rock, so my search began. Besides the reviews having seemed to be a good match for what I was looking for, I had a certain amount of faith in Andrew Jones, knowing that he has designed some very good speakers.
I have only had them in my system for a couple of days, so of course there will be a few months of system adjustment as well as the difficult mental adjustments that take place when you (or at least I) get new speakers. That said, I really think that these are wonderful at reproducing music. They're very full bodied, but not at all slow or sluggish, and voices are a bit larger than past speakers I've owned and very intimate, with a level of detail that I haven't had before, but without any exaggerated treble.
Bass is as advertised, very good. Solid, deep and impactful. It isn't loose at all, which didn't surprise me since the woofers have rolled surrounds which are pretty stiff, and he came up with a scheme of opposing magnets at the voice coil (no, I don't really understand it) that is supposed to make the movement of the driver much more controlled.
It'll be a good while before I can really know the speakers in and out because it always takes me a while to get the comparative sound of my previous speakers out of my head, but I am really enjoying these. I'm also wondering what other member's experiences with them have been.
Thanks @mapman. I neglected to mention one of their strong attributes that I really value in a speaker, which is coherence. It was one of the things that made me stay with the Klipsch Epic CF 4’s for so long despite some other minor failings. Once you hear a speaker that is really coherent, it is really a must. |
@roxy54 yes, agree regarding coherence. |
Nicely done. A good example of what you'd hope to read when you open a post on an audio forum. Happy to hear you've found the right speakers for you On a side note, I've always thought the Klipsch CF-4s were one of the most "under appreciated" speakers We were a Klipsch dealer and also involved in performance mods. We did a fairly ambitious upgrade on a pair of CF-4s a while back. When completed, I set them up for the typical post-mofication sonic evaluation. I'll just say that it took a family intervention to remove me from the listening chair. They were that good!! |
Agreed. I liked the CF-4's so much that they were my everyday speakers for 15 years. Their strong points were coherence and dynamics. They also had an amazing sense of musical flow, but after exposure to a different speaker two years ago, I realized that they also glossed over many details that gave beat and timing cues to me while I was listening. I sold them with regrets, but also wonderful memories. The MoFI's, like any speaker are not perfect, but they are closer to my ideal than I have heard before in my system. I'm feeling fortunate. |
Thanks @ozzy62 . It feels even better when you realize that it's an improvement, not just a different flavor. |
@roxy54 , do they take a good bit of oomph to drive? |
Reading the specs on those is what made me curious, @roxy54 ; however, although I thought I remembered that the nominal impedance is 6 ohms, as you just typed, I also saw that minimum impedance doesn't seem to drop real low, and I am starting to get the impression from all that I read on this site that maybe minimum impedance is more critical than sensitivity. At least when it comes to how hard a load a speaker presents to an amp. However, I may be mistaken in my interpretation of what I have read. |
The importance of impedance, personal experience. Years ago I owned Duntech Princess speakers which I loved. They were rated at 90 dB efficiency but required more power than expected by that. I believe it was due to the response curve dipping just below 3 ohms in the bass. The two best amp matches I found were first the VTL 300 monos with KT-90 outputs, then the Parasound Halo JC-1 monos. The latter were rated at 400 w @ 8 ohms and 800 @ 4 ohms. The Princesses really came alive with those. Otherwise that might seem excessive for 90 dB, so look at the entire response curve. |
Impedance and phase angle.
**Interpretation of Phase Angle** - **In-Phase**: A phase angle of ( 0^circ ) (or ( 0 ) radians) means the voltage and current are in phase, resulting in maximum power transfer. **Power Factor** ### Summary |
Anyway, @roxy54 , congratulations on the new speakers! |
Congrats @roxy54 the triple 8s are an exceptional value to my ears. Exceptionally strong bass (spectacular really), midrange very good and dynamics are also very good. I liked what I heard but with the Class D amp they sounded brash and slightly unrefined. I bet your Mac has the perfect synergy with them. Let them burn and and enjoy! |
Thanks. I think he’s a pretty brilliant guy. I was really interested in the sourcepoint 8 and 10 when they came out because I understood the advantages of concentric drivers having a little second hand experience with Tannoy speakers. The first time I saw pictures and a description of the 888’s though I was really excited, because I knew from past experience that the concentric driver would perform at a higher level if it didn’t have to reproduce those low bass notes. Besides that, I’ve never been a subwoofer guy. I prefer an all in one tower, and these leave everything I’ve owned in the past in the dust. The solidity and clarity as well as tunefulness of the bass performance is really something special. I’m still learning about them every day, and as is usually for me, getting the full measure and understanding of them will probably take at least 6 months. |
I did want to add one important finding, even at this early stage for the benefit of anyone who might be considering these speakers. I read once and saw on youtube another time that these speakers are only for medium to large rooms but based on my past experience with another large speaker and m desire for full range output, I took the chance and bought them anyway. I'm happy to say that they are fine in my 13 x 11 x 9 room. Occasionally a note may hit the room's resonant frequency and you'll hear it, but it's infrequent and doesn't bother me. I'd also mention that my room is untreated. |
Try and find this much engineering effort sunk into a 5k floorstander by a guy elsewhere... Andrew Jones discussion - Mofi 888 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9nV7J0MTFk Andrew Jones discussion - Elac Adante (scroll over to 8:00) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ika420Ezb30
Last i heard, Daryl Willie will just buy a focal driver and drop it in his 80k ghastly looking box (easy peasy incoherency).
|
I want to be clear in my feelings about the Kismet Reference. I believe that Klaus, and whomever else was responsible for the design, have squeezed every bit of performance from these two fine drivers, and in some ways it is better than any other speakers I have owned. For instance, I can say at this point that even though the tweeter on the 888 is very well integrated into the voicing of the speaker, it is not the equal of the beryllium Scanspeak in the Kismet. That tweeter is so pure and smooth and had very wide dispersion. I know from experience that some speakers with beryllium tweeters are too bright, so I have to think the design of the crossover has something to do with it too. |
My thoughts are the op displays quite a bit of wisdom and discernment about relative merits. Sure Andrew is fantastic but there is no monopoly of engineering talent w ears. i agree 6 months is a good milestone to understand the inchstone nuances of a speaker / room combination… so glad you are enjoying the 888. |
@roxy54 -- Interesting speakers, the MoFi’s, though I’ve yet to audition any of their models. A local dealer recently became a distributor of the brand, so I’ll go have a listen to them within shortly to get a bearing on their sound - just out of curiosity. In light of the general price range among hifi/high-end speakers I actually expected the model 888 to be more expensive given its size, appearance and rumored SQ, so was pleasantly surprised to find out they retail for $5k/pair. What’s interesting about the MoFi’s to me, apart from what I can assess from reviews/feedback on their sonic imprinting in select areas, is that they’re point sources from ~150Hz on up and that Andrew Jones is the mastermind behind the particular design choices made here (I still find the TAD CR1’s to be among, if not the best of the more compact, low efficiency speaker designs out there I’ve heard, but they are very expensive). A point source speaker has a lot going for it, though as always it’s about weighing compromises and whether what can be extracted from them appeals to you.
Being point source speakers certainly makes integrating them within shorter listening distances easier. |
Great post, I am always delighted to read about a positive speaker upgrade. I have met Andrew Jones at a few audio show and he is very affable and happy to visit. His induction into TAS or Stereophile Hall of Fame, I forget which one, was well deserved. He has made music lovers happy with a range of speakers at all price points. |
@roxy54, I may owe you a vote of thanks. I just placed an order for a pair of Source Point 888s. Because of my age I wanted to simplify and downsize my system. I've not heard the MF Source Point models but have heard previous Andrew Jones' designs. And I've listened to a few Tannoy concentric designs. So viewing a couple of his interviews, plus comments on your post, convinced me to order without hearing the 888s. My room is larger than yours at 28 x 19 x 10, with a couple of side additions. So hope that suits them. Trusting this was a good decision I'll report back in a couple of weeks after they arrive, go through placement experiments, and break in. |